Tol-in-Gaurhoth L: Battle of the Fandoms

[Nogrod]

Originally Posted by Boromir88

Whether you think it's careless, or not, is irrelevant; you are attaching your emotions/opinions to the evidence. Since only a newbie wolf would be that careless, and McCaber is not new to this, thus McCaber is not a wolf.

That logic doesn't hold; if I said only a stupid dog would fall down the steps, and my dog is not stupid, therefor he would never fall down the steps. That statement would false, because my dog has fallen down the steps.

Just look at the evidence for what it is, no attached feelings or opinions, just look at it.

Okay Boro, now you're making me feel good about you.

So the no-nonsense Boro is back and I'm tending to believe in his innocence for now - not so much because of that return even if it helps a bit - but mainly because of the vote by Sally on Day1 and the death of Lal the Cobbler...

And your case on McCaber is surely worth looking at. I'm not sure I'm as convinced of it as you seem to be but I'm thinking it quite plausible for now. But I need to be doing some revaluating before giving a stronger opinion on it.

I'm still somewhat worried about Nerwen and Fëa.

Fëa has played systematically in a way that is anything but transparent - I mean she has been methodically playful / odd which could be perfect disguise for a wolf (or then just an ordo having fun with it).

Nerwen is nice, very observant and careful while throwing votes away... Very much non-controversial in many ways. Just like a sneaky wolf would be. Gah, if we just knew her role it would be a lot easier as I do appreciate her help a lot when she's innocent.

OOC: Lommy & Greenie are down to my place for the weekend and we'll be doing stuff so I won't be around as much I'd normally be at this time of the Day but I'll try to come back before going to sleep to look backwards a few things.