Tol-in-Gaurhoth LII: Star Crossed II: Together for Eternity

[Nogrod]

Good to see someone else around.

I went back checking Brinn's dreams and her posts and it looks pretty consistent (well, were she a baddie she would have looked to it).

There's indeed only one question I'd like to make to Brinn.

So how come you decided to dream of Gwath the Night before even if Fea had made that "revelation" of hers the Day before that already? Somehow you didn't feel it compelling enough to check her out but chose Gwath?

[Brinniel]

About Fea and Eomer: It seems they weren't completely lying. There were three rangers after all; it's just one was evil. I can't believe I was actually right about something without dreaming it...Fea was indeed a cobbler seer.

Well, with Groin's modfire it seems clear enough, but here it is anyway:

++Sally

Though you may call her Juliet.

Originally Posted by Nogrod

So how come you decided to dream of Gwath the Night before even if Fea had made that "revelation" of hers the Day before that already? Somehow you didn't feel it compelling enough to check her out but chose Gwath?

I didn't dream of her because I figured she was evil in one way or another, and wasn't worth my time. Meanwhile, Gwath I had no idea about.

[Nogrod]

Gwath voted for Gollum.
Brinn voted for Sally.

And did you forget to dream last Night Brinn? If you were the real seer giving the information about the result of it would have been a natural thing to do just to give us others an understanding of the situation. I mean if what you have said is true you'd had 2/3 chances of getting us the baddie.

But on the contrary you say:

Originally Posted by Brinn

Well, with Groin's modfire it seems clear enough

So you do not know it for sure?

Something is not right here...

[satansaloser2005]

Originally Posted by Nogrod

Gwath voted for Gollum.
Brinn voted for Sally.

And did you forget to dream last Night Brinn? If you were the real seer giving the information about the result of it would have been a natural thing to do just to give us others an understanding of the situation. I mean if what you have said is true you'd had 2/3 chances of getting us the baddie.

But on the contrary you say: So you do not know it for sure?

Something is not right here...

I'd second this, for I find it very odd too, but then again if I was a lover I'd say the same thing, so what's the use?


Hey, Shasta's being canonical! Woot!

[Brinniel]

Sorry, I realised I probably should've voted Gollum after I already voted.

I dreamt of Sally, which is why I voted her.

Originally Posted by Nogrod

So you do not know it for sure?

I didn't say that. Sally is a lover. I know that for a fact. And Gollum is the other lover because he's the only one left I haven't dreamed of. Unless Di gave me false dreams.

[Brinniel]

For the record:

Dreams:

Night 1: Mac
Night 2: Nogrod
Night 3: Shasta
Night 4: Gwath
Night 5: Sally

Protection:

Night 1: Greenie
Night 2: myself
Night 3: Nogrod
Night 4: myself
Night 5: Gwath

I didn't reveal my record as ranger before because it isn't all that impressive. I protected a lover, plus I protected myself twice...that makes me feel selfish (though as a seer I was truly scared of dying).

Gwath, who did you protect?

[satansaloser2005]

Originally Posted by Brinniel

For the record:

Dreams:

Night 1: Mac
Night 2: Nogrod
Night 3: Shasta
Night 4: Gwath
Night 5: Sally

Protection:

Night 1: Greenie
Night 2: myself
Night 3: Nogrod
Night 4: myself
Night 5: Gwath

I didn't reveal my record as ranger before because it isn't all that impressive. I protected a lover, plus I protected myself twice...that makes me feel selfish (though as a seer I was truly scared of dying).

Gwath, who did you protect?

Wow. Di let you protect yourself? Different indeed.

Heh. Obviously last night he protected you. Other than that he'll have to tell.

Understand we had to at least TRY to kill you last night, Brinn. The game was over either way.

[Nogrod]

Originally Posted by satansaloser2005

Understand we had to at least TRY to kill you last night, Brinn. The game was over either way.

Bah. I was just getting interested if there still was some freaky possibility of a one more twist to this game that would challenge one's brain again to figure it out...

[Brinniel]

Originally Posted by Sally

Wow. Di let you protect yourself? Different indeed.

Yeah, but I think it's usually the case...at least it is half the time.

Originally Posted by Sally

Heh. Obviously last night he protected you. Other than that he'll have to tell.

Understand we had to at least TRY to kill you last night, Brinn. The game was over either way.

That's what I figured since the only shot you had at winning was the event of my death (and even then, only if Groin wasn't modfired)...but I wanted to be sure. Obviously I was a bit nervous during the Night since I couldn't protect myself again and I didn't know who Gwath protected the Night before..

[Gwathagor]

Originally Posted by Brinniel

Gwath, who did you protect?

Kitanna, Nogrod, Aganzir, myself, and you.

[Nogrod]

Are you trying to say Brinn, that you dreamt of Sally and knew she was a lover but still justified your vote with:

Originally Posted by Brinn

Well, with Groin's modfire it seems clear enough, but here it is anyway:
++Sally

What did Groin's modifre have to do with the guilt of Sally if you knew it via a dream? And why is it "clear enough" and not "sure knowledge"?

Were you a seer you would have said something like: okay, it's packed and clear dearies, Sally is a lover and we'll lynch her toDay - we win!", or whatever. But not: because Groin is out it seems clear enough we should vote for Sally!

I kind of suspected your wording with your vote post yesterDay as I said already. And this doesn't look any better. Indeed it's far more suspicious. Are you too excited to win as some sort of a baddie (the last pair of lovers with Gwath?) you forget what you should look like when posing as a seer?

Darn! It looked so easy a few hours ago...

But fun! It's still not sure!

EDIT: Gah, x'd with Sally... hey, where's the sportsmanship Sally?

[satansaloser2005]

Originally Posted by Nogrod

Are you trying to say Brinn, that you dreamt of Sally and knew she was a lover but still justified your vote with: What did Groin's modifre have to do with the guilt of Sally if you knew it via a dream? And why is it "clear enough" and not "sure knowledge"?

Were you a seer you would have said something like: okay, it's packed and clear dearies, Sally is a lover and we'll lynch her toDay - we win!", or whatever. But not: because Groin is out it seems clear enough we should vote for Sally!

I kind of suspected your wording with your vote post yesterDay as I said already. And this doesn't look any better. Indeed it's far more suspicious. Are you too excited to win as some sort of a baddie (the last pair of lovers with Gwath?) you forget what you should look like when posing as a seer?

Darn! It looked so easy a few hours ago...

But fun! It's still not sure!

Ummmm yeah. What he said. *shifty eyes*

[satansaloser2005]

Originally Posted by Nogrod

EDIT: Gah, x'd with Sally... hey, where's the sportsmanship Sally?

Oh don't worry, I'll still have my fun. But I accept defeat with dignity. And stuff and junk. Besides, where there's no coordination there's no hope for a slick save. *cryptic message is cryptic*


Mind that I didn't post until she said it outright though. I may be a bit slow, but I'm not giving up until the fat lady sings/the seer reveals all.