Tol-in-Gaurhoth LII: Star Crossed II: Together for Eternity

[Nogrod]

Sally & Gollum: Why did you chose Agan on the next Night after Gwath had saved me? You had basically a free kill on me but decided to go the other way taking a risk? I mean I really couldn't believe my eyes when I saw I was alive that next Day (I almost decided not to open the computer in the morning to check it out as I was quite sure I was dead - well, luckily I did bother checking it...). Or were you told there were two rangers?

Originally Posted by Di

Oh and I believe Nogrod at one point speculated that I chose the Lovers based on who I thought could sneak by unnoticed. Yes. Yes, I did.

I knew it! Well, guessed it right... but at that point of the game it really felt like that.

Also I take some pride in insisting through the whole game that just two pairs of lovers was not the whole picture of the game. After Fea and Eomer turned out to be cobbler-lovers it all seemed pretty clear game-mechanicswise. But having played with you Di and being in your games before I really had that bad feeling to the end that there might still be some surprises lurking around the corner...

Originally Posted by Rikae

Nogrod et al., I hope I've proven once and for all that I do, in fact, get furious while innocent

But you can imitate that furor as a baddie as well, and to do that in a very believable manner. I'm probably never going to forget your performance in that game a while ago when you as a baddie played like someone who had taken it very personally and were really, personally outraged and hurt about the mounting suspicions on you.

Originally Posted by Rikae

(of course, that probably was an elaborate scheme in itself, designed to make me appear more innocent next time I'm evil, eh, Nog? )

No, I don't think so... Due to that master-performance you made in that earlier game I will probably never be able to believe you when you get personal. Sorry. That is just the effect of that one game. You played it so believably, so heartfeltly hurt that time (while lying) that I just can't consider taking any personal approaches by you in a game seriously just like that... Although that doesn't mean I will have to suspect everytime you do it after this one as I can now see you can do it as an ordo as well...

And don't get me wrong: I love to play with you and I think we share quite a few approaches to this game (like wishing people to actually play) as well as personal traits (like being more upset when suspected heavily as innocents!).


Looking through all the trouble you went to balance the game I just will bow to your excellent decisions once again Di!

[Rikae]

Originally Posted by Nogrod

No, I don't think so... Due to that master-performance you made in that earlier game I will probably never be able to believe you when you get personal. Sorry. That is just the effect of that one game. You played it so believably, so heartfeltly hurt that time (while lying)

Yeah, well, like I said after that game, I wasn't "playing" or "lying". I was honestly mad that Mac was being suspected for no good reason - for personal reasons - I wanted him to play longer. But I suppose you've decided that I was "lying" after the game too.

[Nogrod]

Originally Posted by Rikae

Yeah, well, like I said after that game, I wasn't "playing" or "lying". I was honestly mad that Mac was being suspected for no good reason - for personal reasons - I wanted him to play longer. But I suppose you've decided that I was "lying" after the game too.

Well. You were a wolf and you made a show which brought "fear and trembling" over everyone involved... and many started to doubt their suspicions of you because of that - I myself as well - to the brink of turning around and not wishing to lynch you... (and I felt so lousy until I found out you were actually a baddie)

I mean I really felt bad at some point and was honestly thinking that we had made a cardinal mistake and that you were really personally hurt... I didn't think of it back then as a defence of Mac but as a defence of yourself - and as you were a wolf anyway - that is not a too unfair an interpretation. Or is it?

Okay, let's not fill this thread with old games... PM me or I'll PM you a bit later Rikae?

Love you anyway! And I love you both as you well know. Mac also, who suspects me in every game - when he is not a baddie...