Werewolf LIII: The Republic

[Thinlómien]

Alright, Nerwen, your explanation makes sense. I will now rightaway admit that I'm partly so suspicious of Boro and tp because I didn't understand their ploy and feel a little dumb right now. But that is not to say there isn't anything fishy in their behaviour.

Originally Posted by tp

Oh, you don't say? You should really go ask Dancing Spawn about the time I tried to set her up to die. I was an Ordo in that game too.
Lommy and Nogrod might remember that. It was in their WerePenguin game.
I believe I also lied that I was the Hunter in that game. But no doubt lying about being the Hunter means that you can't possibly be innocent in your book.

I don't remember you doing that, but I do remember the hunter-ploy. But whatever you did back then has hardly any importance now - if you really did set up Agan to die you would have done even if it was your first attempt at getting innocents killed in this manner.

But anyway, what I was intending to talk about was this whole Boro-phantom mess. There are (surprisngly) three options:

1) They're both innocent and did indeed intentionally cause Aganzir's death to protect the seer and remove an innocent lynch target.

2) They're both guilty, and are having a little joke and enjoying it tremendously, or then just trying to cover their tracks.

3) One of them is a wolf and tricking the other while laughing evilly. (As a sidenote, if this is the case, they totally deserve it and we others should let them quarrel in peace. )

Originally Posted by the phantom

So, Agan died. I'm sad, because I trusted her. Plus she's all smart and pretty and stuff.
But on the bright side I wasn't killed. So guess what? You all get one more day of Phantom!

Sounds like tp set Agan up for the kill so that he would survive never mind the seer...

And is this, in any way, more than a little contradictory?

Originally Posted by Boro

Oh just my luck, I hope the wolves really don't think the intelligent villagers will fall for such an obvious trick?

Originally Posted by Boro

Nice job, tp, I should have known you would have caught on. I thought you were going to start a Nog/Boro war and get me lynched. Well, maybe I'm speaking too soon.

So, first Boro is the victim of a wolvish staging to make him look guilty, and then he's a cunning ww played who was intending to get ordo-Aganzir killed all along?

Originally Posted by tp

4) The Seer has almost certainly checked us by now.

Really, forget about that nonsense. Why would s/he have? Many seers leave loud players aloud just because it's easier to read them or they might get killed and focus on the submarines...

All this talk of tp's troubles me. He's using heavy means of allying himself with Boro and his arguments and ploys are rather wild. He may claim he did intentionally get Agan killed. That might be true. But it's just as probable that he just made this explanation up afterwards, or even worse, had it all planned in his wolvish mind all along... I don't trust him, at all. All that - the wolves falling for his "masterful" ploy etc - just looks a bit too smooth...


edit: xed with Nerwen