T-I-G LVI: Panic at the Prancing Pony

[Mirandir]

Two more innocents dead...This can not be allowed to continue, guys. At this rate the wraiths will have the village overrun in no time flat.

And on that note, I am off to bed. (Yes, I did stay up much later than was probably healthy in order to see who got killed. Sigh. Busy day Thursdays are, but I shall be around nonetheless (bringing the laptop to work? Very possible. ).

[Nerwen]

Some thoughts on yesterDay's voting:

Well, I'm sorry about Menel.... except that what did he have to do something so evil-looking for? Worse than Fea. What's with this village?

I suppose it's remotely possible that Mac is an innocent also infected by the vote-as-evilly-as-possible virus, but I doubt it. He's too experienced not to know that what he was doing was a recipe for disaster. I really don't think I'm being biased: if that wasn't the vote of a cobbler afraid of lynching a wolf by accident, I will drown myself in one of my own brewing vats.

EDIT: word left out.

[Nerwen]

Originally Posted by Mirandir

Two more innocents dead...This can not be allowed to continue, guys. At this rate the wraiths will have the village overrun in no time flat.

Specifically, unless we get a wraith toDay or the Ranger makes a successful protection toNight.

[Nerwen]

Aganzir
Mirandir
Rune
Lari.

Two of these people are wraiths

Aganzir: I don't see any reason to suspect her. Helping save me yesterDay is something an Aganwraith might do, to win my trust... but I'm certainly not making a "just in case" vote toDay.

Rune: *shrugs* Overall, has done innocent-looking and evil-looking things in about equal numbers. I don't know what to make of him.

Lari: Well, she's either the Ranger or she's lying her head off– it's that simple. Openly jumped on the bandwagon yesterDay– but is that too obvious for a wraith? (The cobbler might do it, but I think Mac's the cobbler). Changes her list of who she protected– which looks pretty bad, but could be just carelessness– she gets the voting count wrong later.

Mira: Another openly bandwaggoning vote... again, too obvious? Makes cryptic remark (soon before DL) about having a case against Beregond as "wolf/cobbler", then forgetting it. I'd like to know what that was about, as it's quite a weird thing for an innocent to say, newbie or not. It seems to me that if she's a wraith, she might have been paving the way to get Berry lynched if necessary.

[Nerwen]

I have to go now, so

++Mirandir

as currently the most wraith-like... but I'll definitely be back later and will change this if I see reason to do so.

Please, no silly voting this time!

[Macalaure]

Originally Posted by Nerwen

I suppose it's remotely possible that Mac is an innocent also infected by the vote-as-evilly-as-possible virus, but I doubt it.

Of course, a knee-jerk vote against somebody who made a weird vote against you is so much less suspicious...

Originally Posted by Nerwen

I thought, in his last post but two, he was saying he wasn't going to vote people just because Legate found them innocent.

No, not just because. I limited myself to them because I thought it was a good idea, and still do, and then chose the most suspicious-looking out of the four, which was you.

Originally Posted by Aganzir

a suspected wolf could try to pretend to be the ranger as well.

Yes, but it's a lot less likely. No wraith wants to sacrifice himself to flush out the ranger. It's not worth it.


Nerwen and Aganzir teaming up to lynch somebody who counts as innocent is very, very suspicious. The fact that both also consider Miri as an option makes me feel a lot better about her.

It's Beregond who steers the whole thing into Menel's direction, but he's innocent.

Originally Posted by Aganzir

Of the people alive, Menel looks the most suspicious, but he has done some pretty innocentish-looking things as well

This doesn't only smell bad, it reeks. And people call my reasoning bad. Considering how much talk there was about how crucial yesterDay's lynch would be, this reasoning can't be explained with carelessness, it is willfully malign.

Originally Posted by Aganzir

Anyway, he's suspecting 2/3 of those I find innocent

So?

Originally Posted by Aganzir

Many people thought Legate was killed by someone whom he suspected, what does Mac do? Decides to go and vote for someone he found innocent.

Did they? I have to check again, but as far as I remember, only you and Rune were certain about it.