Middle-earth Bad Popularity Cup

[Legate of Amon Lanc]

Originally Posted by the phantom

The fact that Eol was responsible for creating the best sword ever, the "Iron of Death" or "Iron of the Flaming Star", which led to Turin being named Mormegil (the "Black Sword"), tips the scales in favor of the Elf-smith.

Well, yes, this is true. If for anything, I would vote him because of this. However, as Nerwen said,

Originally Posted by Nerwen

someone has to vote for the WW.

So

++Carcharoth

And also simply because I believe Eöl is not that good to get into another round; and Carcey has, in my opinion, less chance of winning the next one.

I'm leaving this open, if somebody else votes, though.