Game Thread: Werewolf- this time it's real!

[Feanor of the Peredhil]

++Sally

I kind of meant to do this yesterday, though I'd much prefer not to specify why...

[satansaloser2005]

Izzy, I've been after Kent most of the game, so while you can accuse me of going for an easy lynch you can not say that I'm jumping onto it. Just sayin'.


Blah, the smell of alcohol and everything in this silly pub is making me ill. Perhaps it would be best that you all lynch me, because then at least I know I won't be killed by Vamp Girl at Night and have the possibility of vote suckage.


EDIT: x'd with Fea. Oh lovely.

[Gwathagor]

Originally Posted by satansaloser2005

Blah, the smell of alcohol and everything in this silly pub is making me ill. Perhaps it would be best that you all lynch me, because then at least I know I won't be killed by Vamp Girl at Night and have the possibility of vote suckage.

I don't like it when people dare me to vote them. It's always looks like reverse psychology, and it always has the effect of making me want to vote them.

But this really does look like an attempt at reverse psychology, sally.

[satansaloser2005]

Originally Posted by Gwathagor

I don't like it when people dare me to vote them. It's always looks like reverse psychology, and it always has the effect of making me want to vote them.

But this really does look like an attempt at reverse psychology, sally.

Meh, make of it whatever you want at this point. I don't want to die, but it's one of those "I'd rather be mis-lynched than be killed at Night and give the baddies my bonus votes". Just stating a fact. Basically if you vote me I won't be offended, but I'm certainly not asking you to do so.

[Isabellkya]

Originally Posted by satansaloser2005

Izzy, I've been after Kent most of the game, so while you can accuse me of going for an easy lynch you can not say that I'm jumping onto it. Just sayin'.


Blah, the smell of alcohol and everything in this silly pub is making me ill. Perhaps it would be best that you all lynch me, because then at least I know I won't be killed by Vamp Girl at Night and have the possibility of vote suckage.


EDIT: x'd with Fea. Oh lovely.

Would you agree that 'most of', is at least more than half?

Day 1 - nada word about Kent. Vote for Nienna
Day 2 - nada word about Kent. Didn't vote
Day 3 - #467 is I believe your first mention in regards to Kent.

#469 - you say "concerned by the fact that Kent was after Kuru for perhaps being the cobbler and didn't seem to be bothered much by everyone else. Maybe I'm just paranoid or something."

#490 - you vote for Kent. With the preceding stated reason of "Okay, I know this is a bit silly but I'm going with my gut." Stating this after the vote; " Again, this is hopefully just a placeholder vote until I get back, but I'm actually getting some vibes from Kent and they're not so shiny."

#496 - says

Kent still makes me uneasy, just in general. I don't know what exactly it is, but a lot of the things he's said have made me uneasy and while I don't want to kill him just to find out what he is I'm not going to complain if he ends up dead at the end of the Day, because I keep smelling a Kent....erm, rat.

Day 4 -
#647 (you can even scroll up this same page to see this post).

You vote for Kent.

So as far as I can see Kent's really only suspicious of the people who are suspicious of him, and added a couple more people to the list just to hide that fact. He's been overly defensive and paranoid, thinking apparently that everyone who's after him is a wolf. I rather think it's the other way around, and though I'll feel bad if he's innocent I have too strong a vibe from him to let him get away any longer.

I may be mistaken, but you mind pointing out where you 'went after Kent for most of the game'?
The majority of your "suspicions" against Kent came from Day 3. Which they were mostly vague mentions. I don't think you thoroughly analyzed him, or even "went after" him a single time.

So yes, I think if I say that you jumped on an easy lynch - it is completely valid, and supported by your lack of actually going after him.

X'd with Gwath and Kent x2.

[Isabellkya]

Tooth and nail, Kent?

Maybe you mean.. claw and fang? xD

[Kent2010]

If you were to ask me Sally why I am now not suspicious of you, even if I listed you as a possibility at the start of the day, that is because I have been taking note of the collaborative effort to defend me and those turning the attention on you.

[Isabellkya]

Vote Tally.

Nilp -> Sally(4). 5
Greenie -> Sally. 6
Kent -> Nilp(2). 3
Lari -> Kent(2). 3
Sally ->Kent. 4
Fea -> Sally. 7

Sally 7. Kent 4. Nilp 3.

[Gwathagor]

Originally Posted by Isabellkya

Tooth and nail, Kent?

Maybe you mean.. claw and fang? xD

Doctor Who reference?

[Isabellkya]

No Gwath.

Just a plain ol' werewolf and Vampire reference. xD

[Gwathagor]

Originally Posted by Isabellkya

No Gwath.

Just a plain ol' werewolf and Vampire reference. xD

Oh well. It can be if I want it to.

[Kent2010]

Oops, well the Brinn kill was a misreading, but that still begs the question of how does he conclude Agan and Firefoot were killed because they were easy lynch targets? Since when he analyzed Firefoot's post he suggested they might have thought Firefoot was Luthien. And with Luthien still out there, I assume that is their primary motive, not to cause confusion by taking out easy lynch candidates.

[Kent2010]

I all but came out yesterday as the Seer, but Brinn is the only person--except the Wolves, I'll wager (though they must have known I was the Seer)--who seems to have picked up on this.
-Formendacil

That is why I dropped my entire case against you yesterday, and didn't mention what you said today, because I wasn't sure if you wanted to remain hidden today or not.

I would feel better about Nilp today, I think his explanations regarding all 3 kills is fishy. I don't like when I had asked about Nilp (though it might have been missed in the mass posting boom), the attention turned from defending me to trying to get Sally. But that's just my opinion.

[satansaloser2005]

To Izzy: By most of the game I meant most of the game, not all. Big difference.


Now, to something not about me. Gwath's recent behavior is very curious. First (as in first in the last few hours) he semi-agrees with my opinion of Kent, then says 'oh it's okay he's new', then says that he dislikes the suspicion against the New Kid. I mean it's possible he just changed his mind but it still raises an alram bell if you ask me. (Which no one did, but that's not the point.)


EDIT: x'd from Formie on. Oh, now that's interesting

[Gwathagor]

Originally Posted by satansaloser2005

Now, to something not about me. Gwath's recent behavior is very curious. First (as in first in the last few hours) he semi-agrees with my opinion of Kent, then says 'oh it's okay he's new', then says that he dislikes the suspicion against the New Kid. I mean it's possible he just changed his mind but it still raises an alram bell if you ask me.

Pardon me? Could you explain again, please?

[satansaloser2005]

I have something I'd like to bring up, but I need to find it first. Back soon I hope.

[Gwathagor]

Originally Posted by satansaloser2005

Now, to something not about me. Gwath's recent behavior is very curious. First (as in first in the last few hours) he semi-agrees with my opinion of Kent, then says 'oh it's okay he's new', then says that he dislikes the suspicion against the New Kid. I mean it's possible he just changed his mind but it still raises an alram bell if you ask me. (Which no one did, but that's not the point.)

See, what I don't understand is where you think I changed my mind.

[Shastanis Althreduin]

Kent, everyone keeps repeating it because you keep bringing it up. That's a circular argument.

[satansaloser2005]

Originally Posted by Shastanis Althreduin

Kent, everyone keeps repeating it because you keep bringing it up. That's a circular argument.

Thank you! It's like "does no one see the big gaping holes in the logic of Kent's plan?" *hugs Shasta and hopes he's not a nassssty wolf*

[Kent2010]

Why are you so certain we will fail if you are lynched toDay?
-Isabellyka

Because the score will be 5-3, or if Finrod has a successful protection 4-2. All it takes is one more day.

[Kent2010]

Kent, everyone keeps repeating it because you keep bringing it up. That's a circular argument.
-Shasta

I'm sorry I always have a need to get in the last word, but if it helps I'm done. And I want to tell you all to pay attention to the white washing of the Brinn kill that Nilp did, in trying to suggest she was killed because she would have been an easy lynch.

[Isabellkya]

I thought the score was currently 7-3.


X'd with Gwath, Kent, Sally

[Shastanis Althreduin]

Originally Posted by Isabellkya

I thought the score was currently 7-3.

Kent is saying that if we kill him and he's innocent, the wolves will either kill an innocent at night or be revenge-killed by Finrod at night. If the wolves kill an innocent, it would end up being 5 - 3; if Finrod suicide-kills a wolf, it would end up being 5 - 2.

X'd with Kent, Gwath, Sally.

[Shastanis Althreduin]

Look -

It's 7-3 now.

If we lynch an innocent, that drops to 6 - 3.

The wolves kill an innocent.

The score drops to 5-3.

Or:

The wolves attack someone Finrod was protecting. Finrod kills a wolf, but dies in the process.

The score drops to 5 - 2.

Edit: X'd with Kent

[satansaloser2005]

Originally Posted by Kent2010

Because the score will be 5-3, or if Finrod has a successful protection 4-2. All it takes is one more day.

Incidentally, your numbers are off. It's currently 7-3 toDay, and will be either 6-3 or 7-2 toNight. I really hope that was an honest mistake.


EDIT: x'd with Gwath, who does have a point, but I don't want to give a wolf a free pass because of newbie status