The Hunt for Gollum - The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

Erendis · 05-04-2009, 01:57 AM

Oh,you are all such mothers-in-law!
Yes,there were inaccuracies.
Yes,Arithir looked like the spy in "at the sign of the pancing poney"(and why wouldn't he be?)
Yes,I didn't like the Elves-coming-after-the-fight-thing too.
BUT:

All the drawbacks of these realy cute film are almost the same with PJ's.Does any of you dislike the trilogy?
Also,they might have been more original,but I sense that if they had,the film wouldn't have recieved the critics it has.Afterall,like I said in the past,films like that are a motif for the movie-only fans to search more about the books.Guess what would have happened if it turned out to be like the midieval scenes in BBC's documentaries

Come on,guys,we should be supportive!

And let us not forget it is an amateur film!
On my behalf,congratulations!

05-04-2009, 01:57 AM	#25
Erendis Shade of Carn Dûm Join Date: Apr 2009 Location: Imloth Melui,with Yoreth's sister...Just finished the Panadol stock. Posts: 398	Oh,you are all such mothers-in-law! Yes,there were inaccuracies. Yes,Arithir looked like the spy in "at the sign of the pancing poney"(and why wouldn't he be?) Yes,I didn't like the Elves-coming-after-the-fight-thing too. BUT: All the drawbacks of these realy cute film are almost the same with PJ's.Does any of you dislike the trilogy? Also,they might have been more original,but I sense that if they had,the film wouldn't have recieved the critics it has.Afterall,like I said in the past,films like that are a motif for the movie-only fans to search more about the books.Guess what would have happened if it turned out to be like the midieval scenes in BBC's documentaries Come on,guys,we should be supportive! And let us not forget it is an amateur film! On my behalf,congratulations! __________________ Ah,it's good to be home again!