WW LXI: Grimm Tales

[Shastanis Althreduin]

Persons of Interest (re: possible fairytale characters gone wrong)

Aganzir: I think she's still mad at me for last game. Also, her comment about Lommy in her first post today rang a bell for me. It was a nice, shiny bell. A "For Whom The Bell Tolls" type bell.

Gwath: Given that I voted Boro yesterday to be consistent... no, you're not allowed to call me a hypocrite! That was yesterday! This is today! And I feel like he stole my reason from yesterday to hide that his vote is bandwagon-worthy.

Nerwen: I really, really, really think she's innocent. Obviously this means she is evil and should be lynched ASAP, according to my performance last game. Faulty wiring in the head, and mist in the crystal ball, I'm telling you.

Fea: She's under my radar. She's NEVER under my radar. What's going on?!

McCaber: Under my radar (as usual). I want to lynch him (as usual). However, I'm going to push past my prejudice (as usual) and vote someone else (as usual).

[A Little Green]

Hello I'm back here and done with reading. I'll post a list soon, and if someone happens to be around I'd fancy a chat...

[Eomer of the Rohirrim]

A chat, eh Greenie? What is your opinion on trolls?

Shasta, Fea is under your radar only because she's not been around much (too busy it would seem). Rest assured, she will be back to her brash, abrasive and loquacious best soon enough.

So let's string her up while the going's good.

[A Little Green]

Nerwen - Nothing in her rubs me the wrong way right now.
Eomer - Likewise, though to a somewhat lesser extent.
Aganzir - Seems innocentish.
Sally - Not enough material to draw conclusions from.
McCaber - Not so sure about him. I'd love to reread his posts and see what I can find.
Izzy - No idea. (I accidentally typed no die... Seems like my fingers are trying to send me messages. )
Mira - No idea.
Gaurcrist - Too little stuff to draw conclusions from. I'd think, though, that if a wolf his fellows would have ensured he knew what to do?
Shasta - Now we come to the interesting part. I'm still considering him a possible wolf. His "ordo-reveal" seemed pretty wolf-ish to me, I already explained that yesterDay, and even if it was an honest reveal he might have been LRC. And if he isn't a wolf it's quite probable that BBW checked him last Night. So I see practically three chances: either a) Shasta was a baddie from the very start, b) he is LRC and was turned last Night, and c) he's just an ordo. I'm most inclined to think it's a). But be that as it may, he's been so amusing toDay that I feel tempted to leave him be..
Quath - (Sorry for using that silly name, just can't resist!)Nothing alarming if nothing astonishingly innocentish, either.
Boro - I've been flip-flopping about him all through the game. Right now I'm more inclined to think he's innocent. In any case I don't think he's our best lynch candidate toDay.
Kath - She's smooth and sensible and seems okay.
Inziladun - Speaks good sense and seems innocentish.
Fea - I know better than to assume anything about her.
Lari - Too little to draw conclusions from.
Mith - I'm flip-floppy about her too. Generally she's just confusing me.
the phantom - I agree with Izzy that he seems a tad more aggressive than usual. That might just be due to having a bad day or something like that, though, so I won't start drawing conclusions about it yet.


EDIT: x-ed with Eomer

[A Little Green]

Originally Posted by Eomer

A chat, eh Greenie? What is your opinion on trolls?

Trolls are okay as long as they're green.

[A Little Green]

What do you think about McCaber? The guy has started to really puzzle me.

[Eomer of the Rohirrim]

Yeah, it looks like he's trying to feed off the discussion surrounding Boro; suggesting that he's a clever villager who sees gifted hints. Could be genuine.

[Shastanis Althreduin]

Originally Posted by Eomer

Shasta, Fea is under your radar only because she's not been around much (too busy it would seem). Rest assured, she will be back to her brash, abrasive and loquacious best soon enough.

So let's string her up while the going's good.

Clearly her disappointment at Nienna's lynch stems from the simple fact that Fea didn't get to kill her herself. Lynch, I say! Lynch!

Originally Posted by Greenie

Trolls are okay as long as they're green.

I hate having to pay to cross bridges, though. I usually have to answer three questions or some rubbish like that. Hardly fair considering.

Hmm. The votes seem to be Boro 3, Eomer 2, Fea and Mith 1.

I don't want to vote Boro because he needs to redeem himself for the fail-kill last night. Uh! I mean, because I think he's innocent. Yes, that's it. And I don't want to vote Eomer because I don't find him suspicious at the moment (although turn just a hair to the left, Eomer, and I'll see what I can do. )

++Mith

[A Little Green]

DAY 1

1st post: banter, joke suspicions on Lom, Boro, Lari and Nerwen

2nd post: random-ish comments to Boro about the witch and Inzy about his playing style.

3rd post: comments on quiet-loud debate:

Originally Posted by McCaber

Sad but true. You get people who post all over like Lommy and Boro who say quite a bit, and then people like me who often don't have much to say.

It's easier to tell a loud wolf in the lategame because inconsistencies are easier to catch when there's a lot of posts.

And in the past I've been an effective villain by staying rather quiet, so I know from personal experience to get the silent ones first.

I think the contradiction in this is rather interesting, but not necessarily wolf-ish. Actually I'm not sure whether an evil McCaber would want to sort of draw attention to the possibility of him being a baddie.

4th post: says that he'd rather leave phantom alone for the time being and that it's weird to be in Lommy and Agan's good books.

5th post: mainly banter about beer and whisky, says Fea is playing around but it's okay.

6th post: tells that he's going.

7th post: votes Nienna to save Boro.

Originally Posted by McC

Shop's just about to close. A strange day, to say the least.

As I want Boro to live at least another day, my vote has to be

++Nienna

Because I'm pretty sure I can see what he's trying to do with this.

I'm uneasy about this until Mr. McC answers my little (green) questions I asked earlier.

DAY 2

8th post: says yesterDay's voting wasn't that bad because he got plenty of material from the votes. Says that the wolves want to cause confusion and that though Nienna wasn't the best possible choice she was better than Boro. I still want to know why he trusts Boro.

9th post:

Now that's interesting. I wasn't really considering either of them yet, but it's good for the future.

Can I apologize for today? I didn't do a lot here, but I'll be back a good 2 hours before DL. Preliminary thoughts run anywhere from Agan to Fea, and I still rather like Boro and tp.

Agan? Fea? Where did they come from?

That's all he's posted this far. Conclusions? It seems my vague bad feeling about him was mostly caused by his vote post yesterDay where there were too many questionmarks for me. I don't know whether reading through his posts helped me at all. Before, I had no vibes whatsoever except for very slight bad ones. Now I have both good and bad vibes about him and don't know what to think.

I'm not convinced either way.


EDIT: x-ed with Shasta