WWLXII: Dead Men Do Tell Tales

[Macalaure]

Alright, I messed up there. It's late here, too. I didn't read properly. Forget what I replied to this before (though Lommy will predictably not and ramble about me talking myself into bags).

Originally Posted by Boro

But the second part...if we're at most 2 wrong lynches away, and you're the Ranger, what good would lynching you tomorrow do us?

As with Izzy, I was putting myself into Mith's position. For her, lynching me today or tomorrow doesn't make much of a difference, but for me, it would save my life (if only very briefly), and for the village it gives a chance to lynch a baddie.

[Thinlómien]

Originally Posted by Macalaure

As with Izzy, I was putting myself into Mith's position. For her, lynching me today or tomorrow doesn't make much of a difference, but for me, it would save my life (if only very briefly), and for the village it gives a chance to lynch a baddie.

Yes and if you really were the ranger, you'd certainly be alive toMorrow.

[Macalaure]

Originally Posted by Lommy

but that ranger claim really was the last nail to Mac's coffin.

How many last nails does my coffin have? Are you actually implying that you still had a doubt before?

Originally Posted by Lommy

Others have proven it's inconsistent

Aha? I think you're inventing your own facts, like the one that my case against Eonwe was oh so useless.

[Thinlómien]

Originally Posted by Macalaure

How many last nails does my coffin have? Are you actually implying that you still had a doubt before?

Errr quite many.

Originally Posted by Mac

Aha? I think you're inventing your own facts, like the one that my case against Eonwe was oh so useless.

It was useless! And you can't claim Nogrod and especially Boro have had good points that disprove your claim.

Originally Posted by Boro

Sure just go ahead and blame me for it...

I'm just offering you a crumb of the glory.

Originally Posted by Boro

Doesn't mean you aren't a cobbler-Lommy now though who is trying to protect a wolf by causing such a stir about Mac...hmm but would cobbler-Lommy be up this late and going off a few hours of sleep? Probably not.

I think the main thing that disproves my cobblerism is the fact that I attacked Mac so strongly so early and stuck to it, so basically Mac would have had to play very innocentishly to provoke such reaction from me, and he wasn't surely doing that. A cobbler-me wouldn't have tried so hard to get him lynched if there was any chance he was evil.


edit: xed with Nogrod and Mac

[Nerwen]

Back. Reading.

[Nogrod]

Originally Posted by Thinlómien

I think the main thing that disproves my cobblerism is the fact that I attacked Mac so strongly so early and stuck to it, so basically Mac would have had to play very innocentishly to provoke such reaction from me, and he wasn't surely doing that. A cobbler-me wouldn't have tried so hard to get him lynched if there was any chance he was evil.

But a mutineer-you could have done it, especially in a game where no roles were revealed with the death. It would be safe to try it for once in this particular game...

[Thinlómien]

Originally Posted by Nogrod

But a mutineer-you could have done it, especially in a game where no roles were revealed with the death. It would be safe to try it for once in this particular game...

Yes but do you want me to repeat why it'd make zero sense for a mutineer-me to act this way?

[Thinlómien]

Hey you silly people, I can always sleep tomorrow. It's not like a horrenduous sacrifice. It is maybe unwise, it is an overt measure over such a thing as ww, but I felt I wanted to do it. I wanted to ansure Mac's death more than sleep.

And Nogrod in order for this game to end with a mislynch toDay all the mutineers would have to be alive and the ranger'd have to be dead or miss a protection.


edit: xed with the 3

[Boromir88]

Nogrod...alright seriously though, I don't want to get into another sparring match with you at this point in the DL, let's save it for another time.

I do want to ask you something though, if I said Lommy looked oh so sweet and innocent, and couldn't possibly be a wolf based on the innocent feel of her posts what would you say?

[Macalaure]

I guess it's either Lommy or nobody, so:

++Thinlómien

[Nogrod]

Originally Posted by Thinlómien

And Nogrod in order for this game to end with a mislynch toDay all the mutineers would have to be alive and the ranger'd have to be dead or miss a protection.

Who says that couldn't be the case? We know absolutely nothing! And if you manage to lynch the ranger toDay he surely misses it the next Night.

Originally Posted by Lommy

Nogrod, first you say that if Mac didn't make the point he's guilty. You're told he did not make it. You stick to vague phrases like "the baddies are trying to win toDay". Hang on, what's the point?

I'm a ghost already. I don't need to care if I live or die because I'm dead already... so I can talk my mind freely. I agree that Mac looks the most suspicious with things to point straight at... but I just feel soo bad about you and Boro right now.

Why be that nervous about the issue when it looks pretty clear? Mac will be lynched anyway. It looks like life and death issue to you... One solution is, you guys win if you get Mac lynched toDay...

Okay I have said this now (and a few times before this I think).

Originally Posted by Boro

if I said Lommy looked oh so sweet and innocent, and couldn't possibly be a wolf based on the innocent feel of her posts what would you say?

Well she is sweet and mostly innocent (daddy speaking). I agree. But the innocent feel of her posts can be faked as well. On top of being sweet and lovely she's also good in this game... Just reminding you.

[Isabellkya]

While you were glued to Mac, you pretty much ignored everyone else.

++Lommy.

I'm tired, and really don't want to get keyboard face.

[Boromir88]

Oh and I will just say I'm not going to retract. Based on the fact that I just don't buy the reveal. He pretty much took my words that I told to Inziladun as to why Rikae's claim was real. Maybe we have a different definition of "very bad," maybe we don't. Still I don't know how you vote for someone and then determine bad feelings about the lynch, if you know you're the Ranger and are pretty sure about being the only gifted left.

Mac has used me and completely fooled me in the past when I have not had teh guts to act on my suspicion.

Lommy has yet to do that to me, and if she has fooled me. I will apologize to all fellow innocents about making a "stupid" decision. And to Lommy, you can bet you will only get this one, I would challenge you to try and fool me again.