TIG: LXV - Our fate lies with...them? - The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

Macalaure · 08-23-2009, 06:05 PM

Day1:

Form -> Mira (1)
Alona -> Hakon (2)
Sally -> Hakon (3)
Nessa -> Rikae (2)
Nienna -> Pitch (3)
Form -> Nessa (1)

Sally votes with Alona and thus looks bad, though it means very little on Day1.
Nienna's vote for Pitch looks bad, of course, but not condemning.
Form's a bit of a throwaway, but according to him he wasn't aware.

Day2:
Alona -> morm (1)
Nerwen -> Mira (2)
Sally -> morm (2)
Nessa -> Alona (2)
Form -> Inzil (3)
Nienna -> Shasta (1)
Alona -> Inzil (4)
Sally -> Inzil (5)

Sally votes with Alona, again.
Nessa casts a crucial vote against Alona. If Alona had been in really serious danger, it could have been a vote to sacrifice her, but it wasn't so yet.
Form's vote for Inzil looks moderately bad.
Nienna puts in a near-throwaway.
Sally's rescue looks particularly evil.

Day3:

Alona -> none
Nessa -> none
Sally -> morm (1)
Form -> Alona (2)
Nienna -> morm (3)
Nerwen -> morm (4)

Would Nessa really follow Alona with her trick? It looks so risky to me...
Form's vote for Alona looks good, but you have to keep the circumstances in mind.
Nienna's vote for morm looks bad.
Nerwen's vote for him looks good, though (if you discount cobblery), because Alona looked thoroughly dead at that point.

Day4:

Nessa -> morm (1)
Nerwen -> morm (2)
Form -> morm (3)
Nienna -> morm (4)
Sally -> morm (5)

The entire morm-waggon is still alive? Yikes!

That deserves an extra-post.

Day5:

Nessa -> Form (2)
Sally -> Nessa (1)
Sally -> Lommy (2)
Form -> Lommy (3)
Nienna -> Lommy (4)

Nessa voted for a wolf already, though without lynching her. If she and Form are wolves, this vote would have been really risky.
Sally's willingness to switch votes could point to her being a wolf and not caring which innocent dies.
Form and Nienna had it easy to follow my lead. It looks bad for both.

Two/three votes that would have been risky for a wolf. I just don't believe that Nessa has a pokerface like that. She's not a wolf. I'm also willing to believe that Nerwen, if not the cobbler, is not a wolf. That narrows it down.

08-23-2009, 06:05 PM	#11
Macalaure Fading Fëanorion Join Date: Mar 2006 Location: into the flood again Posts: 2,911	Day1: Form -> Mira (1) Alona -> Hakon (2) Sally -> Hakon (3) Nessa -> Rikae (2) Nienna -> Pitch (3) Form -> Nessa (1) Sally votes with Alona and thus looks bad, though it means very little on Day1. Nienna's vote for Pitch looks bad, of course, but not condemning. Form's a bit of a throwaway, but according to him he wasn't aware. Day2: Alona -> morm (1) Nerwen -> Mira (2) Sally -> morm (2) Nessa -> Alona (2) Form -> Inzil (3) Nienna -> Shasta (1) Alona -> Inzil (4) Sally -> Inzil (5) Sally votes with Alona, again. Nessa casts a crucial vote against Alona. If Alona had been in really serious danger, it could have been a vote to sacrifice her, but it wasn't so yet. Form's vote for Inzil looks moderately bad. Nienna puts in a near-throwaway. Sally's rescue looks particularly evil. Day3: Alona -> none Nessa -> none Sally -> morm (1) Form -> Alona (2) Nienna -> morm (3) Nerwen -> morm (4) Would Nessa really follow Alona with her trick? It looks so risky to me... Form's vote for Alona looks good, but you have to keep the circumstances in mind. Nienna's vote for morm looks bad. Nerwen's vote for him looks good, though (if you discount cobblery), because Alona looked thoroughly dead at that point. Day4: Nessa -> morm (1) Nerwen -> morm (2) Form -> morm (3) Nienna -> morm (4) Sally -> morm (5) The entire morm-waggon is still alive? Yikes! That deserves an extra-post. Day5: Nessa -> Form (2) Sally -> Nessa (1) Sally -> Lommy (2) Form -> Lommy (3) Nienna -> Lommy (4) Nessa voted for a wolf already, though without lynching her. If she and Form are wolves, this vote would have been really risky. Sally's willingness to switch votes could point to her being a wolf and not caring which innocent dies. Form and Nienna had it easy to follow my lead. It looks bad for both. Two/three votes that would have been risky for a wolf. I just don't believe that Nessa has a pokerface like that. She's not a wolf. I'm also willing to believe that Nerwen, if not the cobbler, is not a wolf. That narrows it down.