WW LXXV: It's Always Tea Time Here

[Aganzir]

Originally Posted by Nerwen

Isn't it obvious? Mira's saying the lack of information probably means a Ranger save, but she's recently played in a game where the same thing meant the Cursed had been found. So it seems an odd assumption to make.

Ahh okay, I got it. It was mostly that "Mira was dead by then" part that confused me.

So... thanks for the answers, although you mostly just commented on my case and only answered a few of the questions I asked you.

Originally Posted by Nerwen

The fact that I commented on wintywinty's random vote on Day One.

Commenting is fine by itself. But your comment looked sinister. Yes I know there wasn't much to talk about yet and we had to start from somewhere, but there was just something about the comment, the way it was phrased or something. I don't think you can answer to it any better, but it's still creepy.

What does your comment about wolf tactics tending to run in cycles actually mean and could you give some examples?

Originally Posted by Nerwen

Since I only suspected him, rather than knowing his role, I also tried to be fair by bringing up points in his favour as well as those against him.

That's alright. But when it has happened with every wolf we've lynched, it makes one wonder.

You said you wouldn't ignore the Lottie-voters (Lommy, Green & Legate) because the circumstances of the bandwagon were odd. Why were they odd?

Originally Posted by Nerwen

Yes. That was before I'd analysed him and seemed a possibility at that point.

Maybe I'm just a more single-minded player, but when the seer is killed by the wolves, my first thought isn't usually that they wanted to frame somebody.

Originally Posted by Nerwen

There's a question of whether Sally honestly believed she had a chance of changing the outcome at that point (right on DL).

What does this comment have to do with anything? I just didn't get what you were trying to say.

Originally Posted by Nerwen

Brinn's comment was out of context, in that she makes no mention of the fact that

It was a single comment. You made a big number of it. I personally don't think she was distorting what you said, in the sense that it represented your tone towards Glirdan quite well. Take it or leave it, you looked somewhat wishy-washy when it came to lynching him. That's the impression I got and I wasn't the only one.

Originally Posted by Nerwen

Yes, Greenie said he looked innocent, but she said that about a lot of people– we can't know for sure.

So when the seer says somebody looks maybe the most innocent of us all, it means nothing?

When I came I just skimmed through Nerwen's answers and was like alright she seems to be making sense... But it quite looks like she had tried to avoid certain questions. Which doesn't make me feel any better about her.

I agree with Legate the remaining gifteds could maybe start to consider revealing... There are 10 of us now and if they revealed, it would leave only 7 (or 6, if the ranger made a succesful save and was told of it) unknown people. Yes it would make finding the cursed easier for the wolf (unless she already did it), but at the same time it would narrow the field of potential wolves.

Originally Posted by Legate

if the Cursing did happen toNight, I would be most worried about Lommy then

Me too, but we can never be certain... There are simply too many ways for the wolf to act. Thus far they've killed those that looked the most innocent but we have no way of knowing how long that pattern will continue.

Originally Posted by skip

Ergo, a wolf would imo have the strongest motivation to make that retraction move, without saying that an innocent couldn't do the same.

If you must choose between yourself and an unknown and you know you're innocent, it's better for you to kill the unknown (expecially now that the seer is already dead). So I don't think Nerwen's retraction to improve her own chances of survival tells us anything about her role.

I like Shasta's analysis of Mira.. If Nerwen is not a wolf, Mira would probably be my second bet.

Originally Posted by Lommy

Aganzir is also starting to worry me, but this will probably annoy her because I don't have any rational reasons.

No it would annoy me if you did have reasons because they are bound to be bad.