WW LLXVIII: Yar Har Har and a Bottle o' Rum

[Macalaure]

Process of elimination.

Not going to vote:
Inzil, Nerwen, Rikae, for reasons stated before, BG, because it's my first game with her, Wilwa, since she's the only one I feel innocent right now, Boro and Elf-warrior, since they're not with us toDay.

See no reason to vote:
Shasta - he seems fine with me so far.

Slightly uneasy, but not going to vote:
Autume - I can't put my finger on it, but that's certainly not enough to make me vote for her.

this leaves:
Eonwe - most likely my vote right now. The evidence against him has quite piled up. But he didn't get the opportunity to respond to most of it, and I'm afraid we're fueling an ill-advised bandwaggon with no chance of stopping it, and with little evidence resulting from it toMorrow.
Glirdan - I seem to be the only one left suspecting him, which makes a successful lynch unlikely. Worse, Eonwe's jump on him makes it unlikely they're both fishmen, so as long as I'm more suspicious of Eonwe (despite all concerns), I should logically not vote for Glirdan.
Morsul - a bad vote that deserves a lynch. I don't have a good feeling about the success of a shot in the dark with him, though.

[Nerwen]

Arr, me hearties, I be not knowin' who fer to make walk the plank!

Belike I could givin' yon Morsul the business end o' me trusty cutlass, on account o' his suspicinin' o' me fer talkin' in the right proper way o' an honest buccaneer! What kind o' gentlemen o'fortune be he?

...Only, I ha' shipped with he afore, an he be always a suspectin' shipmates fer nothin'. 'Tis but his way, I reckon.

EDIT:X'd with Mac, autume, and Mac again.

[The Elf-warrior]

I think the rule of three thing is no good. The odds of the first three being wolves is the same as any other group of three sailors. Personally, I find it suspicious a seasoned sea salt such as Nerwen would give that old fish tale any credibility. However, I have a bad feeling about Rikae's post #15. That smilied first sentence raises my internal warning bell. Yes, it could just be an innocent joke. But that isn't what my gut says. Gonna to review the thread afore I vote, but Rikae, I accuse you.

[Blind Guardian]

Eonwe -> Glidran
Morsul -> Nerwen
Rikae -> Morsul
Wilwa -> Eonwe
Inzil -> Eonwe(2)
Nerwen->Eönwë(3)
mac->Eönwë(4)
Shasta -> Morsul(2)
Autume -> Morsul(3)
BeiGei->Morsul (4)

And possable Rikae

[The Elf-warrior]

I've done a little thinking on the rule of three thing. With twelve sailors, the odds of one of the first three to speak up being a fishman is one in four. The same odds also apply for the other three groups of three, but I no longer think it suspicious of Nerwen for bringing it up. Looking at the first three is convenient and traditional, and it is day one. Although one foul creature has brought it up in the past that me memory shows me.

[Nerwen]

Originally Posted by The Elf-warrior

I've done a little thinking on the rule of three thing. With twelve sailors, the odds of one of the first three to speak up being a fishman is one in four.

Nay, 'tis more'n't' than that, lad. Them fish be main excited at break o' day.

[Glirdan]

So, quick list

Innocent
Glirdy

Leaning towards innocent
Mac
Rikae
Zil

Unsure
Wilwa
Shasta
Nerwen
BG
Elf Warrior
Autum

Find Slightly Suspicous
Morsul
Eonwe

Between the two that I find Slightly suspicious...

I'm going to go with my gut this time and vote for

++Eonwe

Between him and Morsul, my gut is telling me to vote for him. He's been overly defensive about some of the smallest things and just seems the fishier out of the two. I've seen Morsul pull this one post and vote thing before and it usually turns out that he's innocent.

[Eönwë]

Well, being the one with the most votes is worrying, but I don't think everyone's looking carefully enough.

Blind Guardian has the most posts on this thread and yet hasn't really said anything of substance, sticking to pointless lists (with the Mod being guilty) and endless vote counts). Which all seems a bit too like she's just wanting to please. While before my suspicion was jokin, as I said, I'm not so sure now.

Zil, though his logic looks sound, looks like he's particularly trying to get me killed as well.

Wacth out for them.

[Eönwë]

Also, Nerwen's probably innocent, even though she voted me.

edit: *dies*

[Paranoia]

And that's deadline. Gifted, Fishmen, and Cultist, start sending in your night choices. Narration'll be up soon; Eönwë was an ordo.

[Blind Guardian]

Originally Posted by Eönwë

Blind Guardian has the most posts on this thread and yet hasn't really said anything of substance, sticking to pointless lists (with the Mod being guilty) and endless vote counts). Which all seems a bit too like she's just wanting to please. While before my suspicion was jokin, as I said, I'm not so sure now.

Wacth out for them.

Really? I have the most count? I'm just an overposter. See my last two games. I know both times it got me killed but I can't help it! Besides, the songs got annoying to some so I stopped. On the vote counts...I got nothing. You're right way to much. I'll try to stop.

Edit: whoops. Okay that was an accident. I won't do it again!

[The Elf-warrior]

Well, I don't think Morsul is suspicious, but I think Eönwë is somewhat suspicious. The thing about fish bein' still awake after a night of killing seems to me to be an unjustified application of the game mechanics to real life.

++Eönwë

[Eönwë]

Originally Posted by The Elf-warrior

Well, I don't think Morsul is suspicious, but I think Eönwë is somewhat suspicious. The thing about fish bein' still awake after a night of killing seems to me to be an unjustified application of the game mechanics to real life.

And how is that? If someone kills at night, they'll be tired in the morning.

[Nerwen]

Me hearties, I reckoned I'd had to go belowdecks afore this, but now it seems I ha' a mite more time.

So, a little more explanation fer me votin' of Eonwe: the lad be main jumpy when poked at, an' be puttin' me in mind o' the thrashing o' a fish out o' water.

'Tis a fair weak suspicion, to be sure, but 'tis early days.

An' then, I be not entire easy wi' yon Morsul-voters, even if the dog did vote me. It be puttin' me in mind o' a rescue party, that it be.

EDIT:X'd with a host; pirate grammar.

[Paranoia]

Twenty seven minutes.

Tick tock tick tock.

[Glirdan]

Oh thank Eru I have more time than I thought!!

[Eönwë]

Just woke up early to see I'm in joint first place with the vote count. Wow. Apparently replying to accusations is evil (according to Wilwa); as is jokingly suggesting that someone is a fishman (or woman, in this case) because they're asleep at the wrong times (autume and others).

edit: fixed link. no x-post, which is scary because it means a lot will happen in these last minutes.