WW LXXIX: Fall From Olympus

[Kath]

Ok, final thoughts.

Mira - I don't really know. If Nerwen's a wolf I think Mira more likely to be, but then she's most likely too good a player to leave such obvious trails. Not sure.

Inzil - just wondering about the choice of BG over Mac. If that's explained well then I'm leaning innocent.

Nienna - was consistent but not so much involved. Not sure.

Nerwen - don't know. Avoiding the BG/Nog thing completely can equally be a sign of a confused innocent or an avoiding wolf. Nerwen I kind of doubt would be an avoiding wolf. I don't doubt she'd be a wolf masquerading as a confused innocent. Not sure about her. Would like to know her role as I find others dependent on it. But that's not a good enough reason for a lynch really.

Folwren - feels innocent. Could be tricksy and false. If a wolf then I think Nerwen innocent. Not sure.

Lalaith - somehow avoided all the hint talk that surrounded Boro/Nerwen/Eonwe. Interesting. A wolf with packmates avoiding it? Or had everyone decided hints meant nothing by now?

Greenie - could have been a wolf going after a beleaguered Mac. Could have been an innocent misunderstanding a Gifted way of playing. Not sure.

Shasta - nothing to go on there.

phantom - well I don't think he's Zeus. Not sure if he's a wolf.

sally - again another who got away with hints. Well, not so much hints as kind of announcing she has some kind of innocent role.

So:
I'd be interested to find out Nerwen's role because I think it will give out quite a lot of information. Lalaith I think could be wolvish. sally could easily be bluffing. Deeper looks at these three tomorrow.

And now to bed.

[Kath]

Oh and sally? Did your roles list about two posts further up.

[Inziladun]

Originally Posted by Kath

Inzil - just wondering about the choice of BG over Mac. If that's explained well then I'm leaning innocent.

Busy, and about to walk out the door for a bit, but I thought I'd address this. As I said (once or twice ) Mac and I seem to have a history of suspecting one another from the start of every game. Because of that, I've become hesitant of voting for him early without more to go on.

[Nienna]

Sally, dear?

[Nerwen]

Originally Posted by Kath

sally - again another who got away with hints. Well, not so much hints as kind of announcing she has some kind of innocent role.

But everyone has a role in this game, Kath.

[satansaloser2005]

Originally Posted by Nerwen

But everyone has a role in this game, Kath.

She said she though I had some kind of innocent role, not just a role in general.

Originally Posted by Nerwen

Er... you call what he did "potential"?

Potentially (and in fact definitely) harmful, yes.


Nerwen, have you taken to not understanding/twisting words?

[the phantom]

Okay then, it may end up that I don't participate at all in the debate today. I'm RL socializing with Tum and Sally (no we're not discussing Werewolf Devin!), plus it's obvious who we're lynching today. If I'm still around tomorrow I'll try and do some good reading and extensive commentary and accusing etc.

And since everyone voting the same way is boring...

++ Sally

[Nienna]

*cough cough* Sally you are avoiding my question.

[satansaloser2005]

Originally Posted by Nienna

*cough cough* Sally you are avoiding my question.

It's fun to see you squirm, m'dear.

[Nienna]

Originally Posted by satansaloser2005

It's fun to see you squirm, m'dear.

Fine then, it's very easy to move you to the top of my suspects list. You are now acting like Wolf-Sally. Not good, my dear, not good. It also doesn't help that Tum suspected you heavily and you had an interesting interaction with Rikae yesterDay.

[Nerwen]

Originally Posted by satansaloser2005

Nerwen, have you taken to not understanding/twisting words?

No, have you? She said you "got away with hints" because you suggested you were an innocent gifted.

Originally Posted by Kath

sally - again another who got away with hints. Well, not so much hints as kind of announcing she has some kind of innocent role.

I was pointing out that that's not fair. It illustrates what I don't like about Kath's approach: she basically wasn't playing the first few Days, and now she's analysing early posts by just skimming and guessing at the context. Yes, I accept that it takes too long to read the whole thing, but I've just got to question how useful it is at all.

As a more general thing, I just don't like it– who does?– when submarine players finally surface late in the game, and then trade on how "clean" they've managed to keep themselves. And we've got a whole fleet of subs in this game (though what subs are doing on Mt Olympus is another matter).

EDIT:X'd with Nienna.

[satansaloser2005]

Originally Posted by Nerwen

No, have you? She said you "got away with hints" because you suggested you were an innocent gifted.



I was pointing out that that's not fair. It illustrates what I don't like about Kath's approach: she basically wasn't playing the first few Days, and now she's analysing early posts by just skimming and guessing at the context. Yes, I accept that it takes too long to read the whole thing, but I've just got to question how useful it is at all.

As a more general thing, I just don't like it– who does?– when submarine players finally surface late in the game, and then trade on how "clean" they've managed to keep themselves. And we've got a whole fleet of subs in this game (though what subs are doing on Mt Olympus is another matter).

Okay, got it now. Sorry, I thought you were questioning her wording on my innocent role hints rather than just role hints. Misunderstood. *blushes*