Werewolf LXXXI: Under the Misty Mountains

[the phantom]

Originally Posted by Inzil

Obvious question first: Why is phantom still alive?

Well, they obviously decided I was bluffing. The only question is, was I? We'll know eventually.

Originally Posted by Inzil

So Lommy, who gave three votes for Lottie, shouldn't be considered as a rep again? She looks pretty good to me.

She's the obvious one, yes. And when I came up with that idea Izzy was still alive (I had the thought early today).

And if you're inclined to extend innocence to Wilwa for her one vote on Lottie, you wouldn't want to vote her for rep either.

Also, don't make me a rep if you're inclined to extend innocence to me for not saving Lottie when I easily could have (by voting Sally or voting for Boro before Izzy cast her vote), or for not double-lynching an innocent Boro alongside her as I could have done.

[Inziladun]

Originally Posted by the phantom

Well, they obviously decided I was bluffing. The only question is, was I? We'll know eventually.

Well, a sane person wouldn't have done what you did if they were the actual Seer. However, I know you aren't quite sane. Still, it would seem a pretty big gamble for the elves to ignore you, when they could have just killed you anyway.

Originally Posted by the phantom

And if you're inclined to extend innocence to Wilwa for her one vote on Lottie, you wouldn't want to vote her for rep either.

She split her vote, so she doesn't look as good as Lommy. And like I said, I didn't much care for her last.

Originally Posted by the phantom

Also, don't make me a rep if you're inclined to extend innocence to me for not saving Lottie when I easily could have (by voting Sally or voting for Boro before Izzy cast her vote), or for not double-lynching an innocent Boro alongside her as I could have done.

Your vote (actually, the lack thereof) and your survival through the Night leave me disinclined to vote for you.

x/d with Nerwen

[Eönwë]

Finally managed to catch up properly.

Originally Posted by the phantom

And if you're inclined to extend innocence to Wilwa for her one vote on Lottie, you wouldn't want to vote her for rep either.

I personally think that makes her more suspicious, because if she was an elf she'd be voting for her packmate, which makes her look better, but because she only used one vote out of the two, she could've just been trying to look good while not decisively trying to lynch her, which would be a good cover for an Elf.

Originally Posted by the phantom

Phantom- Definitely could have saved Lottie by killing Sally, but didn't. Possibly could've saved Lottie by voting Boro before Izzy cast her vote (would she have wanted a double-lynch?). Definitely could've lynched an innocent Boro alongside Lottie, but didn't.

Looks like you're trying too hard.

Originally Posted by Nerwen

If you were the Seer double-bluffing, clearly I'd be doing the village a service by convincing the wolves it wasn't so. Also, if you were the Seer, why would you even suggest that you might be double-bluffing? You know, like you just did?

So that the wolves would think that.

[Eönwë]

Basically, I'm not sure what to think about the phantom-Nerwen argument, but there's something about it that makes me think that they're both on the same side. Either they're fighting Orcs, or both very cunning Elves trying to dominate the Day by confusing all of us. And since they're both very experienced and cunning players, I wouldn't put it past either of them.

Though, obviously, the most probable option is that they're both Orcs that just don't agree (as we know happens so often).