Werewolf LXXXI: Under the Misty Mountains - The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

Kath · 09-19-2010, 08:34 AM

Conclusions ... and before anyone complains, this is ALL based on the previous commentary post.

Not sure:
phantom - yeah, no clue.

sally - suspicious, and not exonerated by Lottie's death. However, I do feel it more unlikely than likely that she and Lottie would have voted the same, so close together, if both Elves.

Celuien - would like to see more from her.

Nog - hmm, hmm. Well, his constant assurances that the Seer will deal with the phantom may just be that he's very confident in our Seer ... but to exonerate anyone with that reasoning isn't sensible. I don't think that's quite what he's doing though. Not sure here.

Leaning innocent:
Nerwen - it's weird. Some posts I read and think she's aggressive and really over-making a point. And then she makes a brilliant post like that sally/phantom/Lottie one and my whole opinion changes. For now I'd say I was fairly happy with her.

Shasta - I'm feeling okay about him.

Greenie - feels innocent.

Legate - like I said feeling good about him.

Rune - would like to see more of him but happy so far.

Eonwe - not convinced about his thinking on phantom's reveal but otherwise I'm happy with him.

Lommy - would like to see more on her thoughts about wilwa, otherwise she feels good.

Leaning guilty:
Inzil - I'm not sure. I actually do feel suspicious of him. I do think it was odd to focus so on phantom's 'reveal'. But maybe I'm too used to dismissing phantom's actions.

wilwa - is playing a little ... 'gleefully' is my word for it which can mark wolvishness. That said, the actual content of her posts seems thought through even if I don't always agree with it. BUt again no reason she couldn't manage this as an Elf.

Now I've been doing this for 3 hours and am tired! I will try to answer questions and keep on track though as I will be around on and off til deadline now I think.

09-19-2010, 08:34 AM	#11
Kath Everlasting Whiteness Join Date: Jan 2004 Location: Perusing the laminated book of dreams Posts: 4,533	Conclusions ... and before anyone complains, this is ALL based on the previous commentary post. Not sure: phantom - yeah, no clue. sally - suspicious, and not exonerated by Lottie's death. However, I do feel it more unlikely than likely that she and Lottie would have voted the same, so close together, if both Elves. Celuien - would like to see more from her. Nog - hmm, hmm. Well, his constant assurances that the Seer will deal with the phantom may just be that he's very confident in our Seer ... but to exonerate anyone with that reasoning isn't sensible. I don't think that's quite what he's doing though. Not sure here. Leaning innocent: Nerwen - it's weird. Some posts I read and think she's aggressive and really over-making a point. And then she makes a brilliant post like that sally/phantom/Lottie one and my whole opinion changes. For now I'd say I was fairly happy with her. Shasta - I'm feeling okay about him. Greenie - feels innocent. Legate - like I said feeling good about him. Rune - would like to see more of him but happy so far. Eonwe - not convinced about his thinking on phantom's reveal but otherwise I'm happy with him. Lommy - would like to see more on her thoughts about wilwa, otherwise she feels good. Leaning guilty: Inzil - I'm not sure. I actually do feel suspicious of him. I do think it was odd to focus so on phantom's 'reveal'. But maybe I'm too used to dismissing phantom's actions. wilwa - is playing a little ... 'gleefully' is my word for it which can mark wolvishness. That said, the actual content of her posts seems thought through even if I don't always agree with it. BUt again no reason she couldn't manage this as an Elf. Now I've been doing this for 3 hours and am tired! I will try to answer questions and keep on track though as I will be around on and off til deadline now I think. __________________ “If more of us valued food and cheer and song above hoarded gold, it would be a merrier world.”