If you could choose character? - The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

Tinuviel of Denton · 10-25-2003, 09:51 AM

Eru, I hate to follow the crowd, but I would like to be Luthien. Because she was a dancer and she was brave and she had true love.

I would actually like to be Eol. He wasn't that bad a person, if you really think about it hard. He loved the night, he loved his metalworking. I think he loved Aredhel, at least until she left him. He hated the Noldor for their killing of his kin and their 'warmongering.' Were I Eol, I think I would have taken Curufin's advice and gone home when I found that my wife and son were heading to Gondolin. And if I had continued to follow them, I would have accepted Turgon's offer of friendship and not thrown a javelin at Maeglin and gotten myself thrown off of a cliff.

Maeglin, eh, Finwe? I guess you would be my son. [img]smilies/tongue.gif[/img]

If neither of those two, I would actually like to be Elwing. Having the speech of birds and being able to fly would be pretty dang cool.

And, last, but definitely one of my weirder urges, I would like to be Maglor. It would have been interesting to be one of Feanor's sons and I think he was the sanest in the lot.

10-25-2003, 09:51 AM	#40
Tinuviel of Denton Ghost Prince of Cardolan Join Date: Mar 2003 Location: Amid the hills and dales of the Shire... or not. Posts: 579	Eru, I hate to follow the crowd, but I would like to be Luthien. Because she was a dancer and she was brave and she had true love. I would actually like to be Eol. He wasn't that bad a person, if you really think about it hard. He loved the night, he loved his metalworking. I think he loved Aredhel, at least until she left him. He hated the Noldor for their killing of his kin and their 'warmongering.' Were I Eol, I think I would have taken Curufin's advice and gone home when I found that my wife and son were heading to Gondolin. And if I had continued to follow them, I would have accepted Turgon's offer of friendship and not thrown a javelin at Maeglin and gotten myself thrown off of a cliff. Maeglin, eh, Finwe? I guess you would be my son. [img]smilies/tongue.gif[/img] If neither of those two, I would actually like to be Elwing. Having the speech of birds and being able to fly would be pretty dang cool. And, last, but definitely one of my weirder urges, I would like to be Maglor. It would have been interesting to be one of Feanor's sons and I think he was the sanest in the lot.