Werewolf LXXXIII: The Nightmare on the East Road - The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

Aganzir · 11-06-2010, 07:47 AM

Form
Complains about the lack of nightkill. On day 4, he says there's a villain in the sally/Agan feud, maybe the Wight but he's inclined to think otherwise, and he thinks it's me.

Kath
The only thing she says about sally is "Question: If sally's the BW ... double lynch possible?"

Greenie
Sally's day 1 vote looked bandwagonish. Unwilling to vote for her on day 3 unless she shows up. Me & sally's row at the end of day 3 made her feel worse about us both. On day 4, she says sally's show of not making sense looks bad, and guesses sally is the cobbler. She's never seen an innocent sally behave like that but can't think of a reason for a wolf or the BW to do so.

wilwa
Would feel bad about voting for sally on day 3 because she'd been sick.

Pitch
A bit of banter on day 1 & day 4.

Nerwen
Inclined to believe Shasta was telling the truth about sally - he would've been silly to try to take her down if he hadn't known she wasn't Ferny.

If someone wants to go through my posts, feel free to do so, but I can sum them up here and say sally was one of my top suspects since day 1.

**

I'd say Greenie and Form look the worst - no one else (who's alive) really commented on my argument with sally, but they both suggested there was a baddie involved. Greenie pointed out sally wasn't making sense (which was true though) and agreed with me she could be the cobbler, while Form seemed certain one of us was a villain (but he suggested it was me). It would've been convenient for the wolves even if I had been lynched - they could've argued, "Well, maybe Agan was on to something then, how about we lynch sally now?" It would've given them the excuse to lynch her without appearing to know more about her.
Kath looks a bit better, but I could see her comment as evil, too (make up for Shasta's death etc). And I think wilwa, Pitch and Nerwen looked quite neutral (which is not to say they couldn't be wolves - or the cobbler - since we don't know how the wolves decided to react to sally).

11-06-2010, 07:47 AM	#11
Aganzir Woman of Secret Shadow Join Date: Oct 2006 Location: in hollow halls beneath the fells Posts: 4,511	Form Complains about the lack of nightkill. On day 4, he says there's a villain in the sally/Agan feud, maybe the Wight but he's inclined to think otherwise, and he thinks it's me. Kath The only thing she says about sally is "Question: If sally's the BW ... double lynch possible?" Greenie Sally's day 1 vote looked bandwagonish. Unwilling to vote for her on day 3 unless she shows up. Me & sally's row at the end of day 3 made her feel worse about us both. On day 4, she says sally's show of not making sense looks bad, and guesses sally is the cobbler. She's never seen an innocent sally behave like that but can't think of a reason for a wolf or the BW to do so. wilwa Would feel bad about voting for sally on day 3 because she'd been sick. Pitch A bit of banter on day 1 & day 4. Nerwen Inclined to believe Shasta was telling the truth about sally - he would've been silly to try to take her down if he hadn't known she wasn't Ferny. If someone wants to go through my posts, feel free to do so, but I can sum them up here and say sally was one of my top suspects since day 1. I'd say Greenie and Form look the worst - no one else (who's alive) really commented on my argument with sally, but they both suggested there was a baddie involved. Greenie pointed out sally wasn't making sense (which was true though) and agreed with me she could be the cobbler, while Form seemed certain one of us was a villain (but he suggested it was me). It would've been convenient for the wolves even if I had been lynched - they could've argued, "Well, maybe Agan was on to something then, how about we lynch sally now?" It would've given them the excuse to lynch her without appearing to know more about her. Kath looks a bit better, but I could see her comment as evil, too (make up for Shasta's death etc). And I think wilwa, Pitch and Nerwen looked quite neutral (which is not to say they couldn't be wolves - or the cobbler - since we don't know how the wolves decided to react to sally*). __________________ He bit me, and I was not gentle.*