Without the Spirit of Fire?

[Sarumian]

Originally Posted by Galadriel55

When talking about roles in a story, Feanor's is more important than Eru's.

I would agree also that Frodo's role in the story is greater then Tolkien's

Let me qote one movie, where Baron Munchhausen says:

Grave face doesn't indicate wit, all stupid actions in the world are performed with that very look. Smile more often, ladies and gentelmen!

With all respect to Feanor, he was unable to see things earnestly and lightly at the same time - at least one elvish feature he lacked. He took himself too seriously - the same happened to Melkor, Sauron, Ar-Farazon, Saruman and Denethor.