T-I-G CIV: Spambot Apocalypse (Game Thread)

[Kitanna]

Originally Posted by Morsul the Dark

But we should decide which of the other two is evil otherwise...

"Shasta, who do you think is evil?"
"Kitanna."

"Kitanna, who do you think is evil?"
"Shasta."

This is of course if BG is lynched and proven nothing more nefarious than a hacker.

I'm at work so I can't go through all BG or Shasta's posts, but as far as they are concerned.

BG didn't want to believe G55 claim, even though the day before the reveal it seemed to me she was leaning toward G55 being gifted (possibly hackerish) but once G55 revealed BG did a complete 180. She wouldn't believe what G55 said based on G55's banter posts. Even though she was leaning toward a more innocent G55 before the reveal. Kind of odd behavior, very hackerish, but clever bots can play their cards right and come out smelling like roses by playing in a such a way, being dismissed as "only an innocent or a cobbler would act like that." To me her vote reinforces this idea. The perfect cover for bot BG to hide behind.

Shasta was all too ready to lynch Boro yesterday. He didn't have much to say until the time of the false reveal and then he immediately jumped onto "we gotta lynch Boro" seemingly without even entertaining the idea Boro might be a hacker. It looked like a classic distancing techinque to instill confidence that he is innocent. Especially in his arguments with Boro about his reveal

Originally Posted by Shasta

In the situation we're in, if you truly are the real Seer, you should have countered the instant G55 revealed as the Seer. We had no reason not to believe G55 - we're at the point in the game where the Seer basically has to come forward with information, so saying you were trying to avoid being drawn out by the Hacker is silly.

A staged performance perhaps? Something Boro and Shasta cooked up in the night to deflect suspcion?

[Shastanis Althreduin]

Originally Posted by Kitanna

"Shasta, who do you think is evil?"
"Kitanna."

"Kitanna, who do you think is evil?"
"Shasta."

Pretty much this.

[Shastanis Althreduin]

Although it does seem a little silly to try and paint someone as evil based on a correct assumption. I suppose, though, if I'd been on Boro's side yesterday, a Bot-Kitanna would then be using that as "evidence" against me.

[Morsul the Dark]

I know... I also assume Legate will be nightkilled if only to avoid the chance of me taking them with me. So I NEED BG to be the bot otherwise It's likely to come down to my vote and only one person wants that...

++BG

[Blind Guardian]

Okay, I'm here (finally).

I'm just gonna say it right now - I'm not a wolf. Heck, my name is Blind Guardian not Bot Guardian.

Anywho, I voted G55 (sorry) yesterday, possibly out of sheer confusion, but mainly because of her constant contradictions in her posts and then saying that she was the S.E.E.R. I hoped at first she was the Ranger, but when Sally died, she became Hacker on my list. (I'm not sure what the Hunter does, I'm gonna go look at the roles again.)

No specific quotes from anyone right now. I need to eat dinner, and the I have to go help some friends build the Ark (from Halo) on Minecraft. I'll be back later tonight. Internet = horrible

[Kitanna]

Originally Posted by BG

(I'm not sure what the Hunter does, I'm gonna go look at the roles again.)

Picks someone he thinks is a bot and should the hunter be lynched or killed in the night he takes his choice down. At this point Morsul won't get to use this. As a village we no longer have a reason to lynch him since he revealed and G55 cleared him. And it's too risky for a bot to attack him just in case he pegged them.

++BG

If BG isn't evil I'll be shocked.

[Blind Guardian]

There's not much that I can say right now, but I've stayed up late reloading this forum and no one's posted...

Good night and good luck

[Legate of Amon Lanc]

Let us finish this, then, and

++BG

Just to be on the safe side.

Btw if I manage, I'd still like to post now some reviews of what were the interactions or what has been said by Kitanna about Boro, Shasta about Boro, and Boro about the two of them - if that might perchance point us in some direction.

And if BG is by some miracle still innocent, then well, need to hire some netrunners next time...