Werewolf XLII, Mist in the Barrow Downs

[Gwathagor]

Originally Posted by Nerwen

And if we find out we were wrong, we are all dead. At least three of us are.

Yes.

[Legate of Amon Lanc]

Okay. A little voting tally. Not that it would be needed.

Shasta => Gwathagor (Gwathagor 1)
Legate => Gwathagor (Gwathagor 2)

Left to vote: McCaber, Nerwen, Gwathagor

Oh, my.

[Gwathagor]

Well, if they weren't suspicious before, Shasta and Legate certainly have been today. I've taken the brunt of the accusation from them today and it has been, like the rest of their posts, generally without substance.


++Legate

EDIT: Crossed, ironically, with Legate

[Nerwen]

Oh God, this is tough... and we're running out of time.

One more vote for Gwathagor is a kill.

Let me think, let me think.

[Gwathagor]

What happens if someone doesn't vote and we get a tie?

[Gwathagor]

9:00! Just vote!

[Gwathagor]

Too late.

NOTE TO MODS: Pleas don't count votes that come before the official declaration of "Time Is Up" as late today! Please! Nerwen and McCaber are in a hard spot.

[Nerwen]

I can see so many reasons for and against all four of you, but here goes:

++McCaber.

Because to me he looks marginally worse than anyone else.

Edit: X'd with Gwathagor (thrice).

[Legate of Amon Lanc]

That will be a toss-coin. Don't even think about it.

Too late, obviously. It's past DL. Votes don't count. Now, Gwath, tell us honestly - what were you? Or should we wait for the narration?

And where is McCaber? He is going to become famous for his late-votes.

[Nerwen]

Sorry, my clock's slower than I thought.

So, are you a wolf, Gwath?

[Gwathagor]

He's faking it. He knows I'm innocent.

[Roa_Aoife]

Deadline. No more votes.

Gwathagor is Dead.

Wolf Victory!

I'm going to leave the final narration for Farael, since this is his game. I'm sure he has an idea of how he'd like to end it.

[Gwathagor]

I tried so hard.

[Legate of Amon Lanc]

Originally Posted by Roa_Aoife

I'm going to leave the final narration for Farael, since this is his game. I'm sure he has an idea of how he'd like to end it.

Well, it doesn't matter if we talk here a little bit, or should we not? There is no other thread to talk and I'm sure lots of us would like to discuss... of course, we may wait for the narration to learn how all the things really were... Do you have any idea when's Farael going to show up?

Originally Posted by Gwathagor

He's faking it. He knows I'm innocent.

Who? Me? Hey...

[Nerwen]

Sorry, Gwath.

[McCaber]

Sorry I'm late. If only my clocks worked once in a while, I could vote more often.

Legate, nicely played. Even now, I cannot believe that you are the evil wolf mastermind.

It probably doesn't matter, but I would have voted Gwath as well.

Nice game, everyone. Too bad to see it end like this.

[Rikae]

Well done, fellow wolfies....
I was pretty sure we'd win when I got the pm telling me who my team was!
*high fives all around*

Gwath, amazing debut -- you really had me worried toward the end there that you would track down one of my comrades! I hope you'll become a WW regular.

Menel, now that you've told me when you dreamt of me, I know you caught me "fair and square" - hat's off to you! You were a formidable foe from the first day.

Macalaure, sorry about letting you be lynched and all, but, you know... all's fair in love and werewolf, etc.

By the way, watching everyone call me "brilliant" since my death has been very enjoyable. Keep the flattery coming...

More comments later -- I'm extremely busy at the moment, but I couldn't resist gloating a bit.

[Legate of Amon Lanc]

Wonderful, wasn't it? Well, McCobbler, I must say in the last few minutes I thought I'm going to kill you if you don't show up. But nicely done, everyone. This was a great game and I hope everyone enjoyed it as much as I did - it was definitely thrilling. I haven't experienced a game in such a way since... since my very first game. Is it a pure coincidence that in my first game, I was also... ahem, okay.

MwahaHAHAHA!

And indeed, I must say with such brilliant packmates it was wonderful to work together, and the game was the more interesting. Great job, fellows. And thanks also to all the other players and to the Mods, for making this game happen! Great, just great!

[Nerwen]

You bastards of wolves.
*shakes fist*

[Legate of Amon Lanc]

Originally Posted by Nerwen

You bastards of wolves.

We like you too

That's for the Lindórië thing

[Nogrod]

Congrats to the wolves! Well played indeed!

I knew beforehand that I was going to be away on Day3 and thence tried my best before it - and purposefully didn't mention it so that the wolves would kill me the Night before so that someone who was actually able to play that Day could play. Sadly the wolves turned sporty just that Night and killed LG...

And their sportsmanship didn't last longer...

But the fact that I was left alive that Night just made me quite sure Legate was the other remaining wolf. During my half an hour yesterDay I tried to read the thread, make a decision, think about the best exit to myself and whether to mention my suspicions in earnest. In the end I thought that if I do not mention Legate being suspicious to me he might let me live on this Day as well... Well, how wrong one can be?

Cool play Legate!

And Rikae was just phenomenal! Without Menel I would probably have bought her story! It really took some character to stick into the facts and ignore her wonderful act - and I can see it was hard to many innocents looking at the tallies that Day...

Outstanding play Rikae!

And McCaber really managed to hide in the shadows. I would have taken a closer look on him toDay had I been alive but I'm not sure if that would have helped...

So sad we lynched you Mac... but you must agree your posting in the beginning of Day2 was more than suspicious...

... and my daughters so brutally killed during the Nights... Oh, I will come back to you nassty werewolves the next time for it...

[McCaber]

Ahh yes, the WolForce truly was with us on this Day.

[satansaloser2005]

....dang it....



Can't really comment right now, as class is about to begin. You nasty little wolfsies earned your victory though. Legate, you evil fellow, you were EXCELLENT. You being a wolf didn't even occur to me until after I was dead, and even then I was questioning my suspicions. Extremely well done, and to you other wolves as well.

Back later to make some more comments.

[Rikae]

Nerwen, sorry about using you for a scapegoat... nothing personal, you know. I had to seize any opportunity I got (I set myself the goal on Day 3 to get as many innocents as possible to vote for someone else.)

It was loads of fun seeing everyone repeat "there must be a wolf among the Nerwen-voters"... *evil grin*

[Legate of Amon Lanc]

Originally Posted by Nogrod

I knew beforehand that I was going to be away on Day3 and thence tried my best before it - and purposefully didn't mention it so that the wolves would kill me the Night before so that someone who was actually able to play that Day could play. Sadly the wolves turned sporty just that Night and killed LG...

Exactly - our original idea was to kill Nogrod that Night, of course, but then we decided not to do so. But on the other Night, we simply could not leave him alive anymore. You missed your train, Nogrod, in the expense of a boat, so to say.

Originally Posted by Nogrod

And Rikae was just phenomenal! Without Menel I would probably have bought her story! It really took some character to stick into the facts and ignore her wonderful act - and I can see it was hard to many innocents looking at the tallies that Day...

Yes, Menel has done well - and btw I believe he dreamt of you on Night 1 and Rikae on Night 2, that Shasta-thing was a thing I made up: confusion sometimes is the greatest weapon.

Originally Posted by Nogrod

... and my daughters so brutally killed during the Nights... Oh, I will come back to you nassty werewolves the next time for it...

Yes, I must say I wanted to apologize to you for wreaking such a heedless genocide upon your family...

Well, should we post some of our Nightly PMs? I'm not sure how much interesting it is, though... there was not much behind all the choices, and lots of what we did can be explained on the thread...

Originally Posted by McCaber

Ahh yes, the WolForce truly was with us on this Day.

Indeed

[Nerwen]

Seriously, you guys were magnificent, each in your own way.

And so were you, Gwath. That was a great first game.

If you want to know, I thought you were probably innocent, but I couldn't defend you properly with Shasta and Legate yelling that we must be wolves together.

And I thought McCaber was a wolf and that he'd be waiting around near the deadline as usual, so I was trying to hold my vote as late as possible– only I crossed with yours on Legate and I messed up the timing.

So, ultimately, this is all my fault.

In atonement, I offer myself up as the first course.

[Legate of Amon Lanc]

Originally Posted by satansaloser2005

You nasty little wolfsies earned your victory though. Legate, you evil fellow, you were EXCELLENT. You being a wolf didn't even occur to me until after I was dead, and even then I was questioning my suspicions.

Thank you!

Originally Posted by Rikae

It was loads of fun seeing everyone repeat "there must be a wolf among the Nerwen-voters"... *evil grin*

Yes. That was one of my favourite lines in the whole game... (it was Nogrod who propagated the idea the most, I remember )

And Gwath... I hope you are not much angry at us. And yes, I will say that openly here, you have done well for your first game. The end was very close. And as I said, a pity I wasn't innocent! I can assure you I wouldn't have gone after you in such a nasty way I did.

[Nerwen]

I hereby propose that Legate should change his name to

Legate of Dol Guldur.

[Nerwen]

Originally Posted by Rikae

Nerwen, sorry about using you for a scapegoat... nothing personal, you know. I had to seize any opportunity I got (I set myself the goal on Day 3 to get as many innocents as possible to vote for someone else.)

It was loads of fun seeing everyone repeat "there must be a wolf among the Nerwen-voters"... *evil grin*

I know... but it seemed logical, didn't it? I still can hardly believe you managed to sucker that many people.

[Legate of Amon Lanc]

Originally Posted by Nerwen

And I thought McCaber was a wolf and that he'd be waiting around near the deadline as usual, so I was trying to hold my vote as late as possible

Well, he should have - had his clock been working properly...

Originally Posted by Nerwen

So, ultimately, this is all my fault.

Yes, it is

Originally Posted by Nerwen

I hereby propose that Legate should change his name to

Legate of Dol Guldur.

Hey, sounds cool!

Originally Posted by Nerwen

I know... but it seemed logical, didn't it? I still can hardly believe you managed to sucker that many people.

Yes, Rikae is just fantastic. She almost convinced even me

[Macalaure]

A lesson that every werewolf player learns early on is that just because somebody disagrees with you, it doesn't necessarily mean he's evil.

In this game, I bitterly learned that just because somebody agrees with you, it doesn't mean she's innocent.


Kudos to Rikae for fooling me entirely and for fooling the majority of the innocents even when a seer dream stood against her. Quite remarkable.

Kudos to Legate and McCaber for securing the victory. If only I would have had more time on the day I got lynched, I would have made a case against you, Legate, and maybe, just maybe, things would have ended differently. Anyway, great showing.

Kudos to Menel for his day-one wolf spotting.

Kudos to Gwathagor for a great debut.

I hope you'll become a WW regular.

Seconded.

And sorry to Aganzir for urging my misled day-one suspicion successfully.

Originally Posted by Nogrod

but you must agree your posting in the beginning of Day2 was more than suspicious...

hmph... maybe... *mumbles something incomprehensible*

[Shastanis Althreduin]

I feel stupid. Sorry, guys.

[Rikae]

Originally Posted by Macalaure

"Originally Posted by Nogrod
but you must agree your posting in the beginning of Day2 was more than suspicious..."
hmph... maybe... *mumbles something incomprehensible*

No it wasn't! Nogrod only says that because he's a sneaky immortal super-wolf!

++Nogrod

[Nerwen]

Of course, Legate of Dol Guldur, even if there'd been time and I'd seen Gwath's vote on you, it would have been a hard decision– because I was more sure about McCaber, and if you were a wolf, too...

Why, then I'd have to accept that on Day 3 a bunch of innocents all decided to lynch me instead of a wolf who had been trussed up and handed to them by the Seer.

To quote Nogrod, when looking over the votes after Rikae was lynched:

Originally Posted by Nogrod

Surely one wolf might have voted for Rikae as well but I can't believe there are two of them - or then this village is the most confused ever seen in the Barrow Downs.

[Shastanis Althreduin]

Worst. Game. Ever.

I successfully voted for the Seer twice and at the end when it counted, I made Nerwen and Gwath out to be wolves when neither of them were.

I deserve to keep dying off day 1!

[Nerwen]

Originally Posted by Shastanis Althreduin

I successfully voted for the Seer twice and at the end when it counted, I made Nerwen and Gwath out to be wolves when neither of them were.

...With the result that both of us favoured you as a suspect!

[Legate of Amon Lanc]

Originally Posted by Shastanis Althreduin

Worst. Game. Ever.

I successfully voted for the Seer twice and at the end when it counted, I made Nerwen and Gwath out to be wolves when neither of them were.

I deserve to keep dying off day 1!

Hey, no way! It was great to play with you for so long - although I know if may sound a little twisted from me... But you enjoyed it, at least, didn't you?

And don't say you were too bad. Take it the other way, positively: say, rather, that we were too good

[satansaloser2005]

Originally Posted by Shastanis Althreduin

Worst. Game. Ever.

I successfully voted for the Seer twice and at the end when it counted, I made Nerwen and Gwath out to be wolves when neither of them were.

I deserve to keep dying off day 1!

I disagree. Notice that I called two of the wolves at the start of the game, and then decided to completely forget about Cabbie and let Rikae live in an effort to kill little Nerwen over there. Although, I still hold that the whole exchange between the two of them looked staged. Then again it was, just not by who I thought.

[Nerwen]

There's something odd here. I thought Gwath's vote and mine crossed, but now that I read the thread again, I see that I posted twice after he voted.

Must have been so anxious I didn't see it, somehow. Ah, well. It's been a comedy of errors all round.

Hi, Sally. Next time you find someone "furry beyond furry", maybe you'll reconsider, hmmn?

You realize the evil McCaber planted that idea about me in your head, don't you?

[Gwathagor]

Originally Posted by Shastanis Althreduin

Worst. Game. Ever.

I successfully voted for the Seer twice and at the end when it counted, I made Nerwen and Gwath out to be wolves when neither of them were.

I deserve to keep dying off day 1!

It's OK. I had you figured for a werewolf as well. I KNEW Legate was bad, but McCaber had me convinced he was innocent.