Survivor : All Star

[Meneltarmacil]

Looks like I picked the wrong bandwagon...

--Elbereth

++Gimli

[mormegil]

I warn you sincerely and honestly, if you do not want Elbereth to win you better get her out now, otherwise she will sweep the final!

[Meneltarmacil]

Rest assured, morm, I want a dragon to win this one. Elbereth goes down next.

[Bêthberry]

- - Elbereth


+ + CHRYSOPHYLAX DIVES


'nuff said.

[mormegil]

Rest assured, morm, I want a dragon to win this one. Elbereth goes down next.

The problem is that nobody goes down after this. It's the final three and we vote for who we want to win. It will be Elbereth and two dragons if Gimli goes. If Elbereth goes it's Gimli and two dragons. If Elbereth is here I can tell you who will win.... :( :mad:

[The Only Real Estel]

True enough morm.

- -CHRYSOPHYLAX DIVES

+ + Elbereth

[Macalaure]

I warn you sincerely and honestly, if you do not want Elbereth to win you better get her out now, otherwise she will sweep the final!

I can't see why Elbereth should win, or even sweep, the final. To me it currently very much looks like Smaug, the little-dwarves-and-hobbits-scaring, war-of-wrath-deserting, can't-survive-three-chapters sorry-excuse-of-a dragon, is going to win.

I've read defenses of Smaug, of Elbereth, of Chrys... the only one I haven't read one of is Gimli. How did he get this far if no one actually cares about him? With all objectivity: He simply doesn't deserve to be in the final three.

++Gimli

[wilwarin538]

The votes at the end of the day are:

Gimli - 10
Elbereth - 4
Chrysophylax Dives - 5
Smaug - 1

Gimli is our finale character to be cast off the island. Since he was so upset that Smaug made it farther then him in the game, Gimli tried to attack him, but Smaug
had secretly hiered some bodyguards, who were able to fight off the insane dwarf.

Thus ends this day.

Your finale three are:

Elbereth from the Silmarillion tribe, Smaug from the Hobbit tribe and Chrysophylax Dives from the Minor Works tribe.

Everyone may now PM me the name of the character who they think should win. Please don't post in the thread, I don't want bandwagoning in this, I want everyone to just choose who they think deserves the title of All Star Survivor. I will check my PMs often so it shouldn't get full.

I will announce the winner in about 24 hours.

You may now start PMing!

[wilwarin538]

All the members of the Downs gathered excitedly into the Survivor stadium, waiting for the results of the votes, and the announcement of the All Star Survivor.

As everyone took their seats Wilwarin walked to the middle of the stadium, the finale three, Chrysophylax Dives, Elbereth and Smaug were standing behind her.

“First I would like to thank all those who participated in the game, I had a lot of fun, and I hope you did to. I would also like to thank Mormegil who covered for me a few times, it was much appreciated.” She paused. “So lets get to this. Now, there was a tie. Elbereth and Chrysophylax were tied with 6 votes each. But it is Smaug that is the winner with 7 votes!”

Smaug stood forward bowing to the crowd, as Elberth and Chrysophylax walked away slowly before being sucked into a black hole.

The crowd cheered happily, and unhappily for those that didn’t vote for Smaug , but most were happy. ;)

Thus ends Survivor All Star!

GAME OVER

Votes for the winner, Smaug
Bethberry
Gil-Galad
Firefoot
1,000 reader
Shieldmaiden4xsword
Meneltarmacil
Rune son of Bjarne

Votes for Elbereth
Glirdan
Macalaure
Nogrod
Volo
Elf-Warrior
Estelyn Telcontare

Votes for Chrysophylax Dives
Mormegil
Kuruharan
Celuien
The Only Real Estel
Diamond18
The Saucepan Man

[Celuien]

If I'd stayed with my original plan, I'd have voted for the winner. But it's more fitting this way, considering my record of Celeborn and Smith supporting. :D

I must admit, I'm not entirely dissatisfied with Smaug's victory.

[mormegil]

Smaug won? Wow, that comes as a shock to me.

For those who want to know I really did want Hama to win. I really wanted him to win the first survivor and he didn't there and so I was going for him all along, with a little help from well placed downers ;), I thought we may have a chance but to no avail. He has a good showing though.

Thanks to all for a wonderful game. These truly are memorable and fun moments. Sorry to all those *rune* I offend :D it's only in fun. :D

[The 1,000 Reader]

Active awesomeness has claimed victory. Go Smaug!

[Gurthang]

Yes, dragon victory! That's all that matters. :D

I should have been paying more attention; I totally missed the vote. :( Oh, well, I would have either voted for Smaug, resulting in the same outcome, or for Chrys, resulting in a tie for the two dragons! Disappointing that I missed out, but it turned out okay... all's well that ends well, I guess. Yeah, Dragons! :D

[Rune Son of Bjarne]

I don't belive it! One of my favourits (from the start) WON ! ! !

I think it is a bit Ironic that Smaug won because TORE was telling people to vote for Chrysophylax Dives in his sig. I saw it 50 min before the voting ended, before that I didn't know that the voting for the winner had started.

[Gil-Galad]

Well there was a better chance of it being a Dragon anyways

now check out Barrow-Downs Survivor located in the Middle Earth Mirth Forum!

[Nogrod]

Three hurrahs for Smaug! Surely one of my favourites from the beginning.

And Gah! How near Elbereth made it! I mean, someone who gives you the stars! Just consider the world without them - how boring as a character that one giving them to us might be... :)

In the beginning this looked grim indeed but the result surely gives me some pleasure. Although I agree with Morm about evicting Hama being most unfortunate. Still of the final trio I liked two and the third one didn't win... :D

Fun!

Thanks all!

Let's make the next one (whatever that could be) even more exciting, making more claims and arguments than in this one!

[Boromir88]

I also honestly wanted Hama to win. I just got deflated and smashed after he was gone as there was no appealing characters to me, not even Smaug. (Thanks for the attempt of those who tried to keep me interested) :)

Great job to you Wilwarin, did what you had to do, and you kept all of us troublemakers in line. :D

[Firefoot]

I too was a little less than thrilled with the final characters. As we got to the end, I realized that I really didn't want any of those characters to win. :rolleyes:

[mormegil]

I also honestly wanted Hama to win. I just got deflated and smashed after he was gone as there was no appealing characters to me, not even Smaug. (Thanks for the attempt of those who tried to keep me interested) :)

Great job to you Wilwarin, did what you had to do, and you kept all of us troublemakers in line. :D


Let's do survivor: Hama where he is the only contestant.

[Rune Son of Bjarne]

Let's do survivor: Hama where he is the only contestant.

Don't forget a bunch of elves you can vote off, before declaring Hama for "Awesomeness Incarnated"

[shieldmaiden4xsword]

Yes I'm sooo glad Smaug won..... :D

[Glirdan]

Grrr!!! He won again!! That's not cool!! Oh well...can't have everything in life...

[The Saucepan Man]

Two Dragons in the final and a Dragon win is fine by me. :cool: :D

[Kuruharan]

Two Dragons in the final and a Dragon win is fine by me.

And it is not at all as if some of us planned and worked for this almost from the beginning...no, not at all. :D :p

Congratulations to Smaug, our first (and probably only) two time winner!

[The Saucepan Man]

And it is not at all as if some of us planned and worked for this almost from the beginning...no, not at all.I cannot imagine what you speak of ... ;)

[Celuien]

Votes for Chrysophylax Dives
Mormegil
Kuruharan
Celuien
The Only Real Estel
Diamond18
The Saucepan Man


And it is not at all as if some of us planned and worked for this almost from the beginning...no, not at all.

I cannot imagine what you speak of ...
We wonders, precious. Aye, we wonders. There's mischief from those two, I'll warrant. :D

It's astonishing that I voted with Kuru, Morm, and SPM in a Survivor thread. What is this world coming to? ;)

[The Only Real Estel]

I think it is a bit Ironic that Smaug won because TORE was telling people to vote for Chrysophylax Dives in his sig. I saw it 50 min before the voting ended, before that I didn't know that the voting for the winner had started.

Oh that? :D No, no, not telling people to vote for him (if I did that they probably would vote otherwise just to annoy me)...suggesting maybe, but not telling. ;)

I too find it ironic that I voted the same way as morm, Kuru, & SpM - especially morm & Kuru.

[Diamond18]

Well, I cannot be too disappointed in the outcome. My only hope for the game at the outset was to have Smaug and Chrysophylax duking it out in the final, as they were the only characters really to excite me in the game. I thought it would be next to impossible so I'm glad it turned out otherwise.

It's no secret I would have rather Chrysi won, but Smaug was my second choice. I mean, he did die a stupid death but he's a Dragon and that counts for something! So congratulations to the big fiery dope. :p

[The 1,000 Reader]

I mean, he did die a stupid death

Well, if it cheers you up, the death was highly situational, and what I call a "hari-kiri death", where the character dies, but in a way that they keep their awesomeness and respect. Smaug, Gandalf, Boromir, Hama, and the Witch-King classify as this.

[littlemanpoet]

I was away for two days and didn't get a chance. I would have voted for Chrysophylax. Oh well. What would you have done with a tie, my dear? :p

[wilwarin538]

With a tie, I would have probably chosen the one I liked the most. ;) Which would have been Chrysophylax, cause he has a cool name.

[The Only Real Estel]

...I would have probably chosen the one I liked the most. ;) Which would have been Chrysophylax, cause he has a cool name.

Why do you think I went with him in both of his Survivors? :D

[Rune Son of Bjarne]

With a tie, I would have probably chosen the one I liked the most. ;) Which would have been Chrysophylax, cause he has a cool name.

It was the same reason I used when voting for Chrysophylax. . .