Tol-in-Gaurhoth L: Battle of the Fandoms

[Macalaure]

Originally Posted by Nogrod

Wouldn't it feel that "looks more innocent than guilty" is giving cleaner papers than "not made me more suspicious"?

Those were just the reasons why I put both back from "suspicious" to "somewhat suspicious". In the end, I gave Gwath the notch over Sally out of gut feeling.

Originally Posted by Nogrod

I have been quite comfortable with Mac's sober attitude towards me this game and was almost delighted when he shared some of my ideas - and I do owe my continued existence in this game to him to be sure (that's pretty tough to overlook - although it would indeed be the perfect trick performed by the wolf!). But somewhere in the back of my head there has been a quiet voice squeaking: "Look, look, he's dangerous now, why is he doing all that? Every other time he's at you from his first post onwards?" (just a slight overexaggeration for the dramatics).

Oh, come on. If you now suspect me for not suspecting you, I shall change my ways back.
There are a few minor things that I could have pointed early out on, but I didn't, because then you would have suspected me in turn and defended yourself in a way that I would have found even more suspicious, and down the drain it goes. This just happened too often in the past and very rarely did it do any good, so I'm trying to change it this time (and in the future, I hope). One thing I do find suspicious about you is your Day1 vote, which is why I did not go as far as to put you on my innocent list so far.
(Rikae mentioned something the same thing, too)

Originally Posted by Nerwen

And Mac gives no reason at all.

There's little reason I had, sadly. I pointed out several times on Day1 that I felt Gwath's tone of voice was off. On Day2 I felt better about him, but out of the people on the voting block, he was the one I still felt worst about.


A remark about Boro's #311. That is a very good point there (if only it wouldn't come from my lone suspect left), and I would extend it. In Brinn's unsure list, there are also several people that she said she needed to pay more attention to. Now, if one wolf gets such a comment, I don't think it is usually given much heed during the night's plotting, but if both get such a comment from someone who they think might be the seer, it might cause paranoia. Next to Nogrod and Sally, those candidates are: Rikae, Nerwen, Fea, and Lal. Both wolves in that list?


Well, my current suspicions are thin, like butter spread over too much bread. I'll better go and reread to address that.