Tol-in-Gaurhoth L: Battle of the Fandoms - The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

Macalaure · 09-18-2008, 09:25 AM

A look at N'Rwen:

Day1: She makes one post pointing into multiple directions and adds some inconclusive things on Gwath. Not her fault she couldn't come back. The one post could come from both baddie and goodie, you can't tell.

Day2: She copies all statements about the Captain into one post. In conclusion, she says Sally is odd (but relativates it, hmm...) and suspects Boro. She goes after Lal a bit and defends Brinn. She doesn't think good of Nogrod and Gwath and takes up a point of mine against Boro and votes him in the end. Apart from the shadiness around Sally, I'm fine with all this, except that she could have tried harder to get support for Boro, which had untapped potential.

Day3: Defends her vote for Boro. Questions the Gwath-voters (which is a neat thing to do if she knew there were no wolves to find in there). #344 doesn't sit right with me at all: She seconds a thing Boro (who later received her vote!) said and makes me, and everyone, give opinions on Lal. Why? Why if you didn't seriously intend to vote for her yourself? This move would make sense if you were trying to see how much support for Lal there was, but first teaming up with Boro and then voting him looks simply wolvish. Of course, if she is a fellow of Sally, why didn't she vote for Lal to save her? Maybe she considered Sally to be a goner and didn't want to get involved in a competing bandwaggon for Lal or Nogrod.

Day4: Defends her vote for Boro (again) and agrees with Nogrod on Boro's innocence now.

I admit that I looked at her in the worst possible light now. But even in a more positive light, pretty this isn't.

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Email this Page
Display Modes
Switch to Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Threaded Mode

09-18-2008, 09:25 AM	#11
Macalaure Fading Fëanorion Join Date: Mar 2006 Location: into the flood again Posts: 2,911	A look at N'Rwen: Day1: She makes one post pointing into multiple directions and adds some inconclusive things on Gwath. Not her fault she couldn't come back. The one post could come from both baddie and goodie, you can't tell. Day2: She copies all statements about the Captain into one post. In conclusion, she says Sally is odd (but relativates it, hmm...) and suspects Boro. She goes after Lal a bit and defends Brinn. She doesn't think good of Nogrod and Gwath and takes up a point of mine against Boro and votes him in the end. Apart from the shadiness around Sally, I'm fine with all this, except that she could have tried harder to get support for Boro, which had untapped potential. Day3: Defends her vote for Boro. Questions the Gwath-voters (which is a neat thing to do if she knew there were no wolves to find in there). #344 doesn't sit right with me at all: She seconds a thing Boro (who later received her vote!) said and makes me, and everyone, give opinions on Lal. Why? Why if you didn't seriously intend to vote for her yourself? This move would make sense if you were trying to see how much support for Lal there was, but first teaming up with Boro and then voting him looks simply wolvish. Of course, if she is a fellow of Sally, why didn't she vote for Lal to save her? Maybe she considered Sally to be a goner and didn't want to get involved in a competing bandwaggon for Lal or Nogrod. Day4: Defends her vote for Boro (again) and agrees with Nogrod on Boro's innocence now. I admit that I looked at her in the worst possible light now. But even in a more positive light, pretty this isn't.