Tol-in-Gaurhoth L: Battle of the Fandoms

[Nilpaurion Felagund]

Me Uchiha Madara, me have Mangekyou Sharingan (Kaleidoscope Copy Wheel Eye), me see Rikae, Nogrod, Brinniel, and Shasta and see them Ordos.

Any suggestions where you would like me to cast my eyes next?

I would like to ask the Ranger not to protect me this NIGHT. They won't dare kill me.

[Mithalwen]

Originally Posted by Nilpaurion Felagund

Me Uchiha Madara, me have Mangekyou Sharingan (Kaleidoscope Copy Wheel Eye), me see Rikae, Nogrod, Brinniel, and Shasta and see them Ordos.


I would like to ask the Ranger not to protect me this NIGHT. They won't dare kill me.

I knew!!!! That was the thought I referred to in my first post today but since I didn't do a Shasta style acrostic I can't prove it Was very glad to see you still alive .

So now Nerwen is pretty well my top suspect.

[Lalwendë]

I must vote early today because I have to go out and I don't know if I'll get a chance later.

Now, I'm being tempted to vote to lynch someone from one of these vomit-worthy love-ins. Go and get a room! Bleurgh. I prefer Boro's style, he's always the Simon Cowell of the game (though I hope he doesn't wear those nasty kex) and I can respect nastiness, because that's what it's all about! Plus it doesn't make me feel sick

Still, nowt will dissuade me from the solid evidence of Page 4. No point voting for Mith today simply because it will be a wasted vote as I can see the way things are going in the love-in. Luckily I have two candidates with overpowering evidence against them so I've still got someone worthwhile to vote for rather than feeling obliged to jump onto some poor soul's bandwagon that's been formed from a shadow and a thought. So I might go for my cobbler candidate.

Nogrod's case for his innocence is well thought out, but there is more convincing evidence on Page 4.

Sorry mate, but you knew it was coming.

++Boro

Hopefully I'll get to check in around deadline.

[Boromir88]

Agreed... but did you miss the post where Nilp says he's the Seer, and has dreamed Nogrod innocent?~Nerwen

Whoops...in that case I will take a look at our wolf-slaying efficianados McCaber and Mac. Perhaps they knew too much.

P.S. SEER, I'm serious, don't waste a dream on another ordo.

P.P.S.

I still so desperately want to know Boro's role.~Fea

It's odd how anytime our paths cross, it doesn't matter whether you believe I'm innocent, you just want to lynch me so you know for sure. To which I will say the feeling is mutual.

[Boromir88]

Lal, I prefer Simon Cowell's mini-me, Piers Morgan. Would it be an all-time WW record if I voted for Lal again?

[Lalwendë]

Originally Posted by Boromir88

Lal, I prefer Simon Cowell's mini-me, Piers Morgan.

He might have better taste in trousers, but he's nowhere near evil enough to match your style

Originally Posted by Nogrod the Nog

He's no wolf. And here I'm going to argue against Lalwendë that Sally's vote which raised a fellow-wolf (Boro) alongside to the lead with her other fellow-wolf (CoD) just a few minutes before the deadline on Day1 is just too far-fetched - whatever "evidence" one manages to read from page 4.

I agree and Page 4 corroborates this. I think he's the shoemaker, and racing off like Michael Schumacher with it. Sally wouldn't have had a clue who the cobbler was, but I think she thought it was me yesterday because she got reight mardy with me when she was panicking yesterday.

Got to say again, you can be almost certain that the only almost certain innocents are Mac and McCaber due to their voting. Plus no really shady behaviour.

Nobody else is really a safe bet. An OK one maybe. But not evens. Despite trying to be pukey

[Mithalwen]

No stomach of concrete elephant for you clearly ..would you like some brandy....

Don't see what is pukey about loving my son. He is adorable. So leave him alone...

Oh no not page 4 again..... personally I think page 3 has been underrated... and the half dozen or so subsequent pages...

[Nogrod]

Okay then... interesting indeed.

Boro's sudden insistence to go after me even if Nilp had kind of shadily revealed himself and given the information. So he wanted to try - until Nilp became more articulate.

And then this:

Originally Posted by Boro

P.S. SEER, I'm serious, don't waste a dream on another ordo.

So the seer should indeed do that? And waste the dream on you because you try to look suspicious by doing that?

Boro = the Cobbler.

He's no wolf. And here I'm going to argue against Lalwendë that Sally's vote which raised a fellow-wolf (Boro) alongside to the lead with her other fellow-wolf (CoD) just a few minutes before the deadline on Day1 is just too far-fetched - whatever "evidence" one manages to read from page 4.


Nilp: if - and when - you're the seer I'd suggest Nerwen for your dream. She could be the last wolf and if not she would be of great help to us as a known innocent.

[Boromir88]

Boro = the Cobbler.

Nogrod, I repeat...I am not the cobbler. Wasn't it I who pointed you specifically to Brinniel mentioning you and sally as her two possible wolves. Thus, the wolves killed Brin because they were afraid she was the seer? Wasn't it I who pointed out on Day 2, Sally's strange reactions to CoD's vote? How did I know? Because I've used that exact strategy successful as a wolf, and it was to sally's misfortune that I was in this village.

See Nogrod, instead of looking at the actual "evidence" you just assume that since I said "don't waste a dream on me" I must be the cobbler. Yet, you completely ignore Lalwende who is still harping about the "page 4" evidence, and that's all she's been going on about for over 2 days now. Nogrod, use your noggin.

[Nogrod]

Originally Posted by Boromir88

Nogrod, use your noggin.

I'm trying, all the time...

I'm getting that cobblery from your performance this far but I'm ready to change my mind if you continue being that convincing (what you said was either true and noteworthy or a masterful deceit). I'm going to do some re-reading after I get my dinner out of the way. But anyway, I'm very much against lynching you (and also somewhat against the seer "wasting" his dream on you) as we are after the wolf here and I'm pretty much confident you're not a wolf for reasons already stated.

I'm still thinking our best bets for the wolf are from the group: Lal, Fëa & Nerwen, possibly Izzy or Mith but that would require a WoW... which is not generally improbable but in this game I wouldn't count on it too heavily.

[Boromir88]

I'm getting that cobblery from your performance this far but I'm ready to change my mind if you continue being that convincing~Nogrod

I admit to looking cobbler-ish, but I think that's the effect of my different playing style than from a usual Boro. I like variety, changing it up a bit, I get bored if I stay the same static Boro.

Enough talk about that, so to give Fea a clearer answer...I would love to see Lal lynched today, that I hope will clear my name from all the cobbler talk.

Alright, known Innocent...

Nilp
Shasta
Nogrod

That's a nice, healthy list, as if the the lone wolf wants to eliminate known innocents during the night, it will take him/her a couple days.

Who I have no reason to suspect/I feel good about.

Fea
Mith

I'm sorely tempted to call for Fea's lynching, just so I'm absolutely certain, but for now I'll keep her (and Mith) out of the equation.

That leaves -

Mac
McCaber
Izzy
Nerwen
Lalwende

I'm not doing this because I have any desire to lynch Mac or McCaber today, but somebody has to do it and not make the mistake of just assuming they are both innocent (like I did when I was the seer and Nogrod pulled a cover over my eyes) when we really don't know for certain. I will probably vote for Izzy, Nerwen, or Lal today, but I'm going to do a Mac-analysis and Mc-analysis to consider a possilble wolf-on-wolf vote.