WW LXXX: It's About Time!

[skip spence]

To me it looked like a random yet honest vote.

Originally Posted by Agan

How can it look honest (or dishonest) when there's so little to base it on?

I dunno what to say. To me it looked like an honest guess. On Day 1 there always little to base anything on (for innocent villagers). But I'm not trusting Eomer in any way.

Originally Posted by me

If she really wanted Fea to live a vote on Elf and not Pitch would make more sense to me.

Originally Posted by Agan

But did she? If you don't have a really strong feeling about someone's role, you don't usually care that much about whether they die or not, so accusing wilwa of not saving Fea by voting the proper person seems far-fetched to me. And actually I think wilwa's reason for choosing Pitch over EW was quite decent. Yes she might be a wolf, but she could also have done it as an innocent.

I seem to remember her saying that the girls looked okay and that she could vote for either Pitch or Elf. That implies that she'd rather see Fea alive than either of these two. I could be wrong though.