Tol-in-Gaurhoth IV (The Saga, erm, Still Continues...)

[Saurreg]

Originally Posted by Eomer of the Rohirrim

Saurreg offered a little "O, well done old boy! It's nice to see someone thinking about the good of the village, even though the plan itself isn't perfect." Clearly, the werewolf's way of protecting his ally yet keeping him at arm's length.

It fits together. (And yes, I am aware that just about every theory 'fits together' and that coherentism is a rubbish theory of truth.)

But there you have my two suspects: the phantom and Saurreg.

If yesterday was anything to go by, don't listen to me. But realise that if the phantom is innocent, the werewolves will kill him tonite if we don't lynch him. So we won't actually lose anything (except, perhaps, the phantom's occasional jovial nature! )

Allow this uncouth furrier to laugh in your face. HAHAHAHHAHA!!!

Everybody could see for miles that The Phantom and I complimented one another and you were the only one naive enough to use this a the basis of your rationale.

Of course no one would listen to you now that you have been cast a suspect also.

"So we won't actually lose anything" That's a very careless and haughty joke to make doncha think - belittling the importance of lynching an innocent individual? Are you sure you're not a werewolf?

We have so many villagers in this round and you have already set your sights on yours truly even without waiting for the others to post, you and Firefoot. What's to say the both of you aren't "complimenting" each other also.