Tol-in-Gaurhoth IV (The Saga, erm, Still Continues...)

[Firefoot]

I seem to have attracted a lot of suspicion while I've been asleep, from Saurreg in particular. I must say that this feels very much like a knee-jerk reaction. Whereas phantom's arguments actually are based on such knowledge as we have, Saurreg's tend to follow this pattern:

Someone else has already pointed out that footie voted for me the last round and am leaning towards me again. She herself admitted that she only voted for me because they was no obvious target at all- a stab in the dark if you like and all because of my post last night (which I have explained myself). Now even before I have posted for this round, she has already chosen to make me her target. I do not know why she would do so even though many of the villagers have not even posted yet. Sounds pretty vindictive to me.

For one thing, did you read my last post? I stated pretty implicitly that I was not leaning towards anyone at the moment, and in an earlier post I said that I wanted to hear what you (and some others) wanted to say before passing judgment. Yes, I find myself suspicious of you, and you are doing nothing to dispel those suspicions (though I do accept your reason for not voting yesterday. My suspicions are no longer based on that). However, you are not my 'target.' I seem to be yours, though, for the mere reason that I voted for and "passed judgment" on you. And, please, don't call me "footie." Nothing against you, there, just commenting.

I am still uneasy with all this voting for Eomer and phantom, for similar reasons as Celuien stated:

I honestly believe that lynching Eomer is a mistake. The only evidence against him is the now notorious slip from day 1 and the phantom's theory that he is involved in a frame-up connected to the death of Azaelia. But Azaelia's death didn't particularly cast suspicion on the phantom more than it could have been used against anyone else.

I don't particularly think that the phantom is a wolf either. The wolves wouldn't pick him simply because he generates so much controversy, whether he looks suspicious or not, that it's easy for them to hide in the background.

So, that being said, I will cast my vote for ++ODDWEN. I think she is more likely to be a wolf than either Eomer or phantom.