Tol-in-Gaurhoth IV (The Saga, erm, Still Continues...)

[Firefoot]

I recommend taking a closer look at Firefoot, unless in my skimmings I missed something important (such as her not actually being alive any more). Either she's bad enough at this that she's been wrong about all of her suspects, or she's trying to frame them up because people think she's trustworthy. Either way, it's not reassuring.

But I was right about both Eomer and phantom, wasn't I?

I am not having a very good time choosing my suspects right now (obviously). Towards the end of voting I was feeling irritated with Saurreg for his comments such as "at least someone here knows what he's talking about." (Note: I said irritation, not suspicion. I'm not ready to blame anybody yet today.)

For what it's worth, yesterday's voting was:

Eomer - 5 (*Saurreg*, Hookbill, phantom, dancing spawn, lmp)
Oddwen - 5 (Nilp, *Celuien*, Firefoot, Esga, Lalaith)
Phantom - 2 (Anguirel, Eomer)
LMP - 1 (Fea)
Lalaith - 1 (Evisse)
Celuien - 1 (Oddwen)

Day 1's voting with newly proven innocents filled in.

Anyway, I'm going to review the thread more closely before making more accusations. Hopefully we can bag a werewolf today.

[Lalaith]

Anguierel, looking for chief prosecutors is not always the right solution, it was after all phantom who drove the Eomer bandwaggon. He just had the wrong end of the stick.
I'll tell you what puzzle is keeping me awake at night - the first day's voting.
Did the wolves vote or abstain? Did sit back to enjoy a wholescale massacre, or did they engineer it?