Tol-in-Gaurhoth IV (The Saga, erm, Still Continues...)

[Lalaith]

The werewolves were quick off the mark tonight, alas young spawn, I'm sorry I suspected you.
For what it's worth, wherever your spirit dances now: after you voted for Esgal - even before we found her to be a wolf - I realised you were innocent, because to come up with this way of minimising villager deaths was not the action of a wolf. It was a good idea, and one I was grateful to follow. I was fairly sure that Nilp was innocent and as for Hookbill, there wasn't time to review the evidence and I felt I was being pressured into making a hasty decision.

What Esgal's death then revealed...well now. The first round of voting now becomes highly significant. Phantom, who voted for Esgal, was the second to vote. My own reading of the voting sequence that followed indicates to me that Feanor is probably an innocent. The others I'm not so sure about. Firefoot's vote for Saurreg could be read in different ways.
And I am well aware, before anyone else points it out, that Day One's voting in no way absolves me from suspicion. I also realise that my vote for Esgal could also be seen as a clever bluff and doesn't absolve me either.