Tol-in-Gaurhoth IV (The Saga, erm, Still Continues...)

[Saurreg]

Anguriel - before this day ends, would you at least post whom you think are not werewolves?

[Anguirel]

Alright.

Celuien is certainly not a werewolf, due to conduct, voting reactions, style, emotional response, yada yada yada.

Saurreg, you are of course the remaining obsolete Shirriff.

Lalaith I could still be wrong about, which would be irritating. But I'm genuinely taken in by her mathematical hopelessness and apparent honesty, not to mention the entente cordiale we seem to have formed.

LMP is a suspect-although our dear Artist has now let go of him abruptly, as a leech lets go of a wound...which puts Fea in the running again.

Firefoot is probably on our side and gifted, but could also be a werewolf, traitorously turning on the doomed Hookbill...

And is Evisse's distinct refusal to see the wood for the trees as suspicious as it seems to me? I suspected her a while back...

[Lalaith]

I'm grateful for Anguirel's trust, and it would be very politic of me to concur with his assessment of me as mathematically hopeless.
But even though I am just a humble wet-nurse, I am a proud woman and in case I should die tonight, I don't want to go down in Tol-in-Gauroth history as a fool. I would like to point out that making a vote-counting mistake in the heat of the last minutes is not actually a sign of congenital stupidity or indeed of lycanthropy. Even our mighty and wise judge Anguirel was caught out yesterday, thinking Evisse had scored a draw. And Firefoot tallied up the scores wrong, in the cool light of morning, after all the excitement was over.

So you see we can all do it.

[Anguirel]

Absolutely. And do all do it. I'd be suspicious of anyone who always got their figures right. Sauron teaches many a mathematics course, so they say...

[Evisse the Blue]

If Hookbill turns out a werewolf, I'd be the least suspicious of LMP, who voted quite early for him today. So in that case, Feanor's suggestion of lynching them both together makes absolutely no sense. The more I think about it, the more I tend to place her on top of my suspect list.

Anguirel, I do see what you're hinting at. The only thing that's keeping me back from trusting you is other evidence. You led the attack against phantom, you're protecting Lalaith whom I still strongly suspect, you did not suspect Esga at all. Now you also seem to suspect me, and since the only certainty I have is of my innocence, that does not add to your credibility in my eyes.

Since Hookbill is doomed, and perhaps justly so, I see no reason to cast my vote. I agree that his death and the one that will follow during the night, will tell us a lot, perhaps all that we need to know.

[Hookbill the Goomba]

Well, to be dead, I feel I still have some things to say. When you all finally see my festering human body in the streets, look to Fea who seems to have am agenda against me for no strongly founded reason.
If anything, this game has taught me not to become a detective

It's been fun guys, but this is my final farewell, good luck with killing those werewolves, and next time, don't kill an innocent.

[Lalaith]

Hookbill my dear, if you are innocent you will not have died in vain, the survivors shall be looking at all sorts of people, don't worry.