Werewolf XXX - Tol-in-Elendili - The Isle of the Were-Faithfuls - The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

the guy who be short · 02-28-2007, 09:19 AM

Lalaith

Her first post is logical - we should not be sharing info on how to find gifteds!

Post 106 is when I first looked at her. She votes for Holbytlass for saing "I'm not sure who we're to pray to." Picking up on language like that seems silly when there's so much else going on. It was also a safe vote - Rikae and Garin had 4 each, Manwe had 3. As such, it seemed a waste of a vote cast for a reason lacking much thought behind it.

Posts 118-9 she tells Rikae to reveal her dream, then says not to because the wolves will kill this person if she does. I'm not sure what to make of this; it could be interpreted for or against Lalaith.

Her final post on day 1, post 129, switches her vote to Manwe to help save Rakae. I think at this point Rakae was already saved, was she not? In any case, that seems fairly reasonable to me.

All her posts today seem perfectly fine to me. I don't regard her as very suspicious after doing this analysis. In fact, I realise that my suspicion stemmed from Roa, who made Lalaith appear Faithful in her analysis. This, if anything, proves the importance of not taking other people's word for it - do research yourself. You are the only person you can trust.

Next, Brinniel.

02-28-2007, 09:19 AM	#11
the guy who be short Shadowed Prince Join Date: Jan 2003 Location: Thulcandra Posts: 2,343	My own suspects Lalaith Her first post is logical - we should not be sharing info on how to find gifteds! Post 106 is when I first looked at her. She votes for Holbytlass for saing "I'm not sure who we're to pray to." Picking up on language like that seems silly when there's so much else going on. It was also a safe vote - Rikae and Garin had 4 each, Manwe had 3. As such, it seemed a waste of a vote cast for a reason lacking much thought behind it. Posts 118-9 she tells Rikae to reveal her dream, then says not to because the wolves will kill this person if she does. I'm not sure what to make of this; it could be interpreted for or against Lalaith. Her final post on day 1, post 129, switches her vote to Manwe to help save Rakae. I think at this point Rakae was already saved, was she not? In any case, that seems fairly reasonable to me. All her posts today seem perfectly fine to me. I don't regard her as very suspicious after doing this analysis. In fact, I realise that my suspicion stemmed from Roa, who made Lalaith appear Faithful in her analysis. This, if anything, proves the importance of not taking other people's word for it - do research yourself. You are the only person you can trust. Next, Brinniel.