Werewolf XXX - Tol-in-Elendili - The Isle of the Were-Faithfuls

[the guy who be short]

Originally Posted by Me, post386

What I notice here is the huge amount of no-ideas. Durelin, Hookbill, Kitanna, Lalaith, Legate. That's far too many people I haven't paid enough attention to.

Let's form some opinions.

There are now too many posts for me to consider going over everything each of these people has said. I shall try to lessen my load somewhat by starting from Day 2. Day 1 is always a stab in the dark anyway.

Durelin

Post 141 - yay-ranger post.

Post 150 - nothing

Post 156 - mildly suspicious of Hookbill, based on Roa's reasoning (pre-knowing she was a cobbler).

Post 216 - Yay Rikae post. Believes firmly in Rikae, which is a good sign I feel. Mild suspicion of Hookbill, Brinniel and Lommy.

Post 228 - Says Roa still has a vote, so she can still do harm. Again, firmly believes in Rikae.

Post 262 - Says not voting for Roa means we might lynch somebody else randomly. Defends Legate for the second time. Accuses Brinniel and Kath.

Post 268 - Votes Roa.

Post 278 - Nothing.

Post 282 - Nothing much.

Post 308 - Accuses mith.

Post 314 - Dear me. A long analysis of everybody. Let's see:
Neutral about Brinniel.
Neutral about Gil.
Thinks I'm innocent.
Neutral about Hookbill.
Suspects Kath.
Defends Kitanna.
Neutral about Lalaith.
Neutral about Legate.
Neutral/ slightly suspicious of Manwe.
Suspects Mith.
Neutral about SpM.
Suspects Lommy.
Suspects Rune.

Post 316 - Nothing.

Post 331 - Defends herself against Lommy's accusations.

Post 364 - Suspects Rune and Lalaith.

Post 389 - votes for Rune. Mild suspicion of Hookbill, Gil. Slight defense of Lommy over her Glirdan slip.

Post 396 - Wants to know how her playing style has changed, according to people.

Post 404 - Defends her vote for Rune.

Post 415 - Nothing.



Well... that took FAR longer than I expected. I don't think I can manage even this undetailed analysis for all five. Nogrod, will you have time to do a few? Hookbill and Kitanna in particular have seemed to escape widespread attention.

It's hard to come to a conclusion on durelin. I don't know her playing style, so I don't see how it's changed. I find nothing to jump on, nothing that seems to shout Faithful. She does, however, seem to post quite often to say nothing much.

I don't really agree with a lot of her reasoning - her attacking Rune, wanting to lynch Roa, etc. But these aren't indicators of Faithfulness, but a difference of style, technique and belief.

I still find her quite neutral. That was a worthwhile analysis.