WW XXXX - The scouring of the Shire, vol.2 - The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

Macalaure · 11-30-2007, 12:21 PM

Lommy - others already noted she contradicts herself a lot. I think a self-contradicting Lommy is an innocent Lommy.

Legate - not sure, but tending slightly towards innocent

Aganzir - spoke sense, though only once

Menel - didn't say much.. appears innocent.. we'll see

Volo - innocent by consensus? Anyway, I think I overlooked his post #42. I'm less suspicious of him now. A good reread does miracles, sometimes.

The Might - confused, very confused. However, confused is not the same as suspicious. I'm tending towards innocent.

morm - not much apart from suspecting Lommy for being self-contradicting, no idea

Fea - genuine, could be anything, hopefully we'll see more tomorrow

Brinn - speaks sense, unspectacular

Sally - is present, but doesn't add much. Slightly suspicious

Farael - mute. I'm against lynching him. It's not fun if they can't scream.

A Little Green - makes me slightly uneasy, but even though she knows the game, she's still a newbie here, so she won't get my vote today

Nerwen - I reread her posts and she still seems not only more defensive than "usual", but more tense - consistently. In #61 she urges us to reread and reconsider. Very sensible, but also very smart to say when you're among the most-suspected.

The idea of Lommy threatening her is very far-fetched.

Valier - her "lynch the quiet ones who have no excuse" is worrisome, but that's all I can find

Kath - I disagree with her vote for the Might. Yes, she had little time, but still voting for a person who merely "caught her eye" is a suspicious thing.

Rikae - very involved. If she's a wolf, she's certainly not afraid to slip. Only few players are more vocal when they're guilty.

Shasta - Shasta?

Kuru - no red flags here - as grumpy as I recall him

That's way too many people looking innocent. I would only be comfortable with a vote for Nerwen or Kath at the moment.

mormegil · 11-30-2007, 12:44 PM

Valier seems far too concerned trying to save herself. The way I understood her posts was that since I usually suspect her and have been sucessful in the past, for better and wose, at getting her lynched she better kill me off. The remaining posts seem to be designed to keep her alive, too much so for me to think her an ordo. Call in knee-jerk if you wish but she seems most suspicious based on that.

++Valier

Lommy seems a bit contradictory but I'm not sure if she's suspicious. I don't trust anybody who votes for themselves so the Might seems reasonably suspicious too. Volo give me the gut feeling of guilty and not only for his first post but he seems a bit frazzeled and that he is trying to be visible and helpful.

Kuru, me wanting to lynch Fea is akin to me wanting to lynch Kath...it's based on principle not reason.

Rikae seems innocent enough for now as does Mac

Feanor of the Peredhil · 11-30-2007, 12:50 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mormegil

Kuru, me wanting to lynch Fea is akin to me wanting to lynch Kath...it's based on principle not reason.

Just so everybody knows: I take no offense to morm trying to kill me. We have a long history of this sort of thing. I want him dead too.

Speaking of that, and more importantly: because he voted for Valier and I don't think he should have,

++Morm

11-30-2007, 12:44 PM	#2
mormegil Maundering Mage Join Date: Apr 2005 Location: Texas Posts: 4,651	Valier seems far too concerned trying to save herself. The way I understood her posts was that since I usually suspect her and have been sucessful in the past, for better and wose, at getting her lynched she better kill me off. The remaining posts seem to be designed to keep her alive, too much so for me to think her an ordo. Call in knee-jerk if you wish but she seems most suspicious based on that. ++Valier Lommy seems a bit contradictory but I'm not sure if she's suspicious. I don't trust anybody who votes for themselves so the Might seems reasonably suspicious too. Volo give me the gut feeling of guilty and not only for his first post but he seems a bit frazzeled and that he is trying to be visible and helpful. Kuru, me wanting to lynch Fea is akin to me wanting to lynch Kath...it's based on principle not reason. Rikae seems innocent enough for now as does Mac __________________ “I wish it need not have happened in my time," said Frodo. "So do I," said Gandalf, "and so do all who live to see such times. But that is not for them to decide. All we have to decide is what to do with the time that is given us.”

11-30-2007, 12:21 PM	#1
Macalaure Fading Fëanorion Join Date: Mar 2006 Location: into the flood again Posts: 2,911	Lommy - others already noted she contradicts herself a lot. I think a self-contradicting Lommy is an innocent Lommy. Legate - not sure, but tending slightly towards innocent Aganzir - spoke sense, though only once Menel - didn't say much.. appears innocent.. we'll see Volo - innocent by consensus? Anyway, I think I overlooked his post #42. I'm less suspicious of him now. A good reread does miracles, sometimes. The Might - confused, very confused. However, confused is not the same as suspicious. I'm tending towards innocent. morm - not much apart from suspecting Lommy for being self-contradicting, no idea Fea - genuine, could be anything, hopefully we'll see more tomorrow Brinn - speaks sense, unspectacular Sally - is present, but doesn't add much. Slightly suspicious Farael - mute. I'm against lynching him. It's not fun if they can't scream. A Little Green - makes me slightly uneasy, but even though she knows the game, she's still a newbie here, so she won't get my vote today Nerwen - I reread her posts and she still seems not only more defensive than "usual", but more tense - consistently. In #61 she urges us to reread and reconsider. Very sensible, but also very smart to say when you're among the most-suspected. The idea of Lommy threatening her is very far-fetched. Valier - her "lynch the quiet ones who have no excuse" is worrisome, but that's all I can find Kath - I disagree with her vote for the Might. Yes, she had little time, but still voting for a person who merely "caught her eye" is a suspicious thing. Rikae - very involved. If she's a wolf, she's certainly not afraid to slip. Only few players are more vocal when they're guilty. Shasta - Shasta? Kuru - no red flags here - as grumpy as I recall him That's way too many people looking innocent. I would only be comfortable with a vote for Nerwen or Kath at the moment.