Werewolf XLII: The meaning of life forever

[Aganzir]

Sorry it took me this long to arrive.

In any other situation, I wouldn't have believed Noggie's claim because he and the way he introduced himself look so plain suspicious. (Well, I admit there's also a tendency to believe those who come out first, but I'm not speaking only about myself now.)

Lommy is a wolf; her way to react to suspicion and just the way she posts convinced me long before her sudden seer revelation. I think we should lynch her today. I find it unlikely that the wolves will attack a hunter who may be protected, and if Nog doesn't need to take care of Lommy now, he will have a chance to kill a wolf later.
And voting Nog is the worst possible idea at the moment! If we kill him now, he will take one wolf with him, but his ability to attack is also something to consider...

Originally Posted by Lommy

So being all the time in character is suspicious in principle and that's why you think I'm a wolf who thinks THE Ka suspicious and thus defends her? Did it cross your mind I don't necessarily think the same way you do, so your conclusions on my behaviour might not be valid?

No, that's not what I think, and don't twist my words. I was speaking about what kind of impression I got from your posts, and that impression includes the idea that you thought like that.
I must say I was pretty surprised to see you're so aggressively defending yourself against reasons that have nothing solid to back them up, only feelings.

Originally Posted by Brinn

Aganzir stands out a little more in my mind because she was the first to state she'd rather vote Shasta because Ka contributes, and that reasoning just doesn't seem very good to me.

And may I ask what you would have done in a situation where both of your contestants look rather innocent, one posts and the other doesn't.

Originally Posted by Menel

You say, Nogrod, that Lommy must be a Wolf since you clearly aren't one. Yet I'm afraid I cannot blindly trust you on that. What evidence do you have that could point toward your innocence?

This is about as wolfy as it possibly could be. "Oops Nog, you've caught my fellow! Surely you don't happen to be a gifted, willing to come forward?"
I don't believe Menel's claim. I think a ranger should have absolutely no reason to come forward now. The wolves couldn't have known if there was a ranger alive, and with good luck they would have attacked Nogrod who would have been protected.
Besides, I think Legate looked like a panicking gifted in his last posts.

Originally Posted by Nogrod

To begin with I'd say that Shasta is/was innocent.

You're even a better player than I imagined if you can figure that out from Shasta's posts.

Of the dead, Legate, Roa and Greenie looked all quite innocent, though Greenie less so after her sudden turn on Rikae (or, the turn was understandable but the way she put it plainly weird). I agree with Nog that Groin might have been a wolf. Lommy's reaction would point at that, and at least to me he looked rather suspicious anyway. About Shasta and Gil I can't say anything.

I don't like Brinn's flip-flopping. I can understand why she voted for Nog, but how she came to that conclusion looks rather suspicious indeed. She looks actually somewhat cobblerish.

Originally Posted by Rikae

However, if Nogrod is not dead toMorrow, we have to lynch him, regardless of Lommy's role, which we won't know for certain anyway - because if he was the wolf and we let him live toMorrow, we lose the game.

I fail to see why.

I find myself disagreeing with Rikae about almost everything, but she feels rather innocent and I'm inclined to trust in her for now.

Originally Posted by sally

I've not played that much with Legate, but I don't believe he would make that much of a fuss if he was a wolf.

While I agree with you that Legate looks innocent, I don't think that's a very good reason to think so. If Legate was a wolf, the best he could do when it was obvious that he would be lynched was to make himself look as innocent as possible - so that we would concentrate on the innocents of their trial day instead of his wolf mates.

Now, the way Isabell dismisses the gifted claims is weird.

Originally Posted by Lommy

Do you wish me to come out with his/her name? I can redream of him/her next Night and if I survive, we'll have a second wolf spotted with good luck.

I'm actually rather interested to see whom Lommy would like us to look at.

McCaber was really trying to be Roa's friend as long as she was alive. I can understand if he had a RL reason for failing to vote, but... Now he comes and tells he would have voted Roa, the player considered more dangerous, even though it looked like he was going to vote Naria rather than her the whole day. Trying to make friends with Naria now? I find him suspicious.

edit: xed with Kath and Zali