Is it possible: 1 Silmaril found: The Arkenstone

[skip spence]

Glad to have won a few folk over. Unfortunately there's a catch I didn't notice at first, being eager an all.

This was an idea that did not fit the chronology, for Melian left Valinor in 1050, the year of the awakening of the elves ... Feanor was born more than a hundred Valian years later ... and in GA 2 the story of the great pearl Nimphelos was substituted.

Oh well...