Werewolf XLVI: Getting Back to Basics

[Legate of Amon Lanc]

Originally Posted by Thinlómien

Especially Gwath and Legate:
What? So Lhuna's lists are "clear" and "helpful" and "statement of fact and not much own opinion" and she "limits herself to facts and not value judgements"? Am I missing the sarcasm or something? While I appreciate Lhuna's lists and find them amusing, I would never use those expressions to describe them. In my opinion, they are full of very subjective interpretation and more joking & bantering than clear and helpful statement of facts. There is nothing wrong with this kind of approach (meaning Lhuna's approach, of course), but there is something wrong with the fact that these two gentlemen interpret Lhuna's posts so very differently from how I do it. I mean, their view seems quite limited, if not even false.

Not sure what I said was well understandable. I definitely did not agree with Gwath's marking of Lhuna's posts as "clear" or "helpful". What I said was not about Lhuna, but about Gwath: I meant that his evaluation of Lhuna's posts seemed logical (the way I understand Gwath, i.e. doesn't mean I agree with him) and spoke for his good. And I thought similarly, that is, that Lhuna may have simply posted "lists", which is nice (speaking now overall of lists, not of these in particular), but it doesn't help as it's just a list and you don't learn anything about the list-maker himself (or you actually may, as his thoughts leak in it whether he wishes or not. But I spoke about it all in the post about it earlier pretty well, I think).

Originally Posted by Aganzir

And I promise to lynch you first if you keep using Japanese words because they are ugly.

All right, I'll stop. I don't know many of them anyway. So:

Aganzir-chan looks innocentish to me, although I am aware that when she looks innocent, she generally isn't and vice versa, however I would like to hope this time it's different.

Gwathagor-kun is more in the yellow line, which makes him one of the most probable lynchees... however... err, I don't like it. Actually I am toying with the idea to lynch someone who has given no evidence at all but just banter (other than Volo, that is). We can always lynch Gwath tomorrow. But there's the thing that I never did that (meaning lynching a silent one), and I would have also to see whom to pick... (The main idea for this is the "deterrent example" to be made for those who don't post... right from the top of my head I am thinking about Oddwen or such, who have posted several times, but posted absolutely nothing of worth, and that is even at the time when there were topics to discuss.)

Lhuna-san looks sometimes strange, maybe she is catching to a good possible lynchee Gwath and not going after me because I may be her support... whatever. She'd be also around the yellow line, also, possibly.

Nogrod-sama looks helpful, although his latter posts give me the worries of possible sinisterness, in accord to what I said earlier. But he's not high on my list (meaning, not high in suspicion).

Lommy-chan looks more like her innocent self even with the latter posts.

Mithalwen-sama I am not viewing that well still, however I am not that sure about her and I will refrain from voting her today.

I see Nerwen-sama has posted as well now, good. One thing to what you said: yes, I have been definitely gibbering more than usual, I am well aware of that, looks like I am like that now. But that's not a matter to worry about. Overall, Nerwen looks innocentish to me from the little I have.

About others, I can't say A nor B, because I can't recall them saying anything interesting.

And P.S. I'll be for ignoring Volo-san's vote today. For myself, I think it was of no significance at all. He simply left for today, and that's it. Not making + nor - from it.

EDIT: x-ed since Kath