Tol-in-Gaurhoth L: Battle of the Fandoms

[Nogrod]

Originally Posted by McCaber

Yes folks, I was very right the first 3 Days. I was trying to be right to try to be killed by the wolfpack instead of the Seer. The whole sacrifice thing, you know.

Uh-oh... Now this looks... well, very strange to say the least.

I think I need to adopt that tactics in the next one I'm an ordo: just be right about everyone so that the wolves kill me instead of killing the seer.

Now what makes me wonder is the motivation issue. Why would an innocent say something like this? Why would an innocent try that kind of posture?


Also I find this a bit disturbing:

Originally Posted by McCaber

Remember the last time two people went head to head in this game? Both were innocents harping on phrases that could be taken badly. I'm sure that if I really wanted to I could put together a convincing argument that Boro is indeed a wolf and should be killed. But I won't, because I think he's innocent.

Boro suspects McCaber and he answers that he could start suspecting Boro and then it would be an innocent against innocent situation (referring to Gwath and me earlier). Now what? There isn't a consistent row between you two and then you say you could turn it into one - which then "proves" you're an innocent because the row would tell us you both are innocents?

Although I still find it hard to believe the lone wolf situation this early was planned by the wolves. Is it possible they just messed it all up?