Tol-in-Gaurhoth L: Battle of the Fandoms

[Nogrod]

Three hurrays for Macalaure!

Hurray - hurray - hurray!

That was incredibly sneaky of you! I have faced a similar situation once before (well it was a bit larger village when I was left alone but anyway) and it was really tough. You managed it admirably! *Kudos*

Originally Posted by Macalaure

I abstained from suspecting Nogrod so much because I thought he was the cobbler (so much for me not auto-suspecting Nogrod this time ), and couldn't turn around on that in the last minute without making myself look bad.

So that was it!
And I was thinking that you were defending me - remember you saved me from the gallows two Days in a row - either as an innocent believing I was not a wolf (for once!!!) or as a wolf trying to make me feel good about you. I had those doubts to the end (my death that is) but it always felt there was a better candidate to lynch... How wrong I was!

And I even made a general post at some phase of the game about the "feel-good factor" and how deceiving it can be... *kicks oneself*

A real gamble - those are always ones I admire - but it was a successful one too. Great work!


And thanks to all others as well! It was a hard one - which means a fun one - even if I would have loved to play it longer.

Originally Posted by Gwath

How do I manage to spend as much time as I do at the top of suspect lists? Am I cursed? Is it something to do with my writing style?
Sigh.
I hate werewolves so much.

Welcome to the club! I'm always suspected and I always end up near-lynched at least on the first Days. Call it the aura or whatever... That's just something you can't avoid - at least I seem not be able to... But I love the game!

And don't blame yourself Izzy for your choices. It's always easy to look back with hindsight and say "I should have done this or that". You risked it with Nilp and that's it: it was a risk I might have taken myself - and many of us might have. If Mac had chosen differently, you'd be the hero of this game...

And anyway, if the ranger manages one save in the game she has performed truly well!