WW LXI: Grimm Tales

[Eomer of the Rohirrim]

Hehe, sorry McCaber, but my guess is that you're the wolf.

#208 - you assert that the wolves probably just want to cause confusion by killing Lommy. Minor point but I never like this comment.

#280 - more substantially, McCaber suspects Aganzir and Fea here, and is still certain of Boromir's innocence.

#565 - this is what really gets me. He is convinced by Aganzir's guilt at a time when I was still torn between who to believe: Aganzir or Izzy.

And that's why I think you're the other wolf, McCaber: because you seemed to know just too much.

[Eomer of the Rohirrim]

Gaurcrist and the phantom - EEEEEVIL!!!

McCaber - sly evil.

Rest: innocent.

Me: Hansel. There are a couple of barely-visible hints in my posts.

Gaan yersel, villagers - gaaan! (That was dialect, not a hint or code - it amuses me, that's all.)

[Inziladun]

Originally Posted by Eomer of the Rohirrim

Hehe, sorry McCaber, but my guess is that you're the wolf.
#565 - this is what really gets me. He is convinced by Aganzir's guilt at a time when I was still torn between who to believe: Aganzir or Izzy.

Hmm. At the time I too was a bit taken aback by this, as I couldn't figure out why Agan (though undoubtedly deserving of suspicion) suddenly was brought into the forefront as the favorite lynch candidate when so much about Izzy had not been addressed.

edit- x'd with Eomer- and a Hansel reveal!

[Nerwen]

Originally Posted by Eomer of the Rohirrim

#565 - this is what really gets me. He is convinced by Aganzir's guilt at a time when I was still torn between who to believe: Aganzir or Izzy.

You may well be right, Eomer – but I can't remember at what point he said that.
Aganzir did pretty much give herself away eventually that Day. (I'll check the context.)

As for the question of revealing– can I just assume my Captain Obvious guise and point out that we don't have a Ranger anymore?

EDIT: X'd with Eomer and Inzi.

[Nerwen]

Well, well. Out of curiosity, who did you use your powers on each Day?

[Lariren Shadow]

I'm here and packing up my room, but I am wondering what that was about the Hunter and the Seer being together. I do wonder what was told to the Hunter.

Now to believe Eomer's reveal is the question, but since it seems like he really needs to leave then its probably legitimate.

[Nerwen]

Originally Posted by Lariren Shadow

Now to believe Eomer's reveal is the question, but since it seems like he really needs to leave then its probably legitimate.

Well, if Eomer provides a list of who he... er... hanselled each Day, we can see if it adds up.

I personally am fairly sure he's telling the truth– but then I was wrong about Fea.

[Eomer of the Rohirrim]

Well, I took away Lari's vote for phantom first day: wasn't fussed about which one of the top suspects died (couldn't choose between them, really). Second day it was Gwath's vote for Boromir I took away - that was a crazy and hectic end where I kept switching back and forth on Mithalwen.

Next two days were obviously meaningless.

I know there's no Ranger; I'm also not certain the wolves will kill me (in order to try and make the village think I'm up to no good). But I think it's early enough to reveal. ie. if there's a competing claim today then fine: the village has caught the wolf (either me or my challenger).

But as yoú'll see, no-one other than tp or Gaurcrist will claim this because it completely gives them away.

So I think I can objectively say you can trust me.