Gandalf Vs. The Witch King

[Mugwump]

Originally Posted by alatar

If his body was invulnerable to harm, he could have simply jumped off and made a run for it. He also is anxious in the claws of the Eagle (if I remember correctly).

Who said Gandalf's body was invulnerable to harm? Certainly not I, nor anyone else here, I think.

[alatar]

Originally Posted by Mugwump

Who said Gandalf's body was invulnerable to harm? Certainly not I, nor anyone else here, I think.

Originally Posted by Mugwump

Yes, Jolt, I do believe that if Gandalf is (as you admit) Ainur, then since the Ainur are neither men nor mortals, but are in fact immortal, therefore Gandalf is neither a man, nor mortal. What is confusing to you about that conclusion? And incidentally, immortals can die, although they do not age.

Sorry; I took the above to mean that you think that Gandalf's body was not subject to nature.