Game Thread: WW LXXXVI - The Halls of Mandos

[Aganzir]

++NOGROD

I have seen enough. Nog if you're innocent I apologise, but at the moment I can't see that as an option.

I am not going to argue with you about if Shasta overreacted or not. Or if he acted stupidly or not.

Originally Posted by Nogrod

As I felt I was one of the scarce people trying to make points and really do something on D1 I could say I found his sudden suspicion and decision a mean one. And I must say he started it. He just made a bad decision there.

But my suspicion wasn't bad and/or mean?

if I feel like doing it after all this crap you guys load on me with no real points to back it...

I'd say you called it upon yourself. You'll probably disagree. Anyhow I find it more likely an innocent tries to help and says "I told you so!" afterwards. Nog is just being a martyr.

Would you be more specific here so that I could make it right? This really baffles me.

No. Or maybe yes but not right now. I'm getting tired of your aggression.

Originally Posted by Nerwen

Actually– even though there's not much need for a cobbler to hint in this game– that post looks a lot like he's doing just that. "Bingo! Nice work, my wolfish mistress!"

That's a good point - not sure if it means anything, but I wouldn't be surprised. Lommy has been awfully eager to fish for cobblers, anyway.

Originally Posted by Nogrod

And of course they killed him and not Nerwen as it was not clear which one or was ot true wiht Nerw, but the two unrelated things both pointed into Shasta being a lover.

You seem to know very much about why Shasta died. Now the question is, did Wolfrod spot a lover and is now irritated about nobody believing he did it? You know, the real reason for someone getting killed is often so obvious to the wolves they can't understand how others don't see it...

[the phantom]

My case against Lommy from yesterday (here) still stands today, and I said earlier today that in my reread I was feeling bad manipulation from Boro, and so now Nerwen's idea of linking them together as Cobbler & Wolf looks quite attractive to me.

So yeah- I'm still totally up for lynching Lommy.

As far as Nog.... *sigh* He felt innocent to me all day yesterday, and even today he doesn't exactly scream "guilt" so much as he seems... something.... odd. I think I and others have demonstrated some flaws in his attacks, and honestly I'm starting to get VERY irritated with the fact that he still hasn't responded to my initial questioning of his opinion on me, despite my prodding.

Meh, I'll decide later. I have an assignment due at 8:00 that I need to finish off. I'll look in periodically.

(edit: sp)