Tol-in-Guarhoth CIX - Ten Year Anniversary Game: Dead Thread

[Nilpaurion Felagund]

Originally Posted by Macalaure

Fierce indeed. Back in the days, I counted the wins/losses of every player. Roa had 15 wins and 4 losses. Best winning percentage of anyone, and it isn't even remotely close.

I stopped at WW75 for some reason. I should update it.

Esty and Mr Underhill have 100% win rates, right? Unless they joined a game while I was away or you have a minimum number of games played requirement.

7 more, village. (I think.)

[Aganzir]

So morm really wants to find out if Lalaith was a wolf or not while Mith downplays it. Morm trying to appear helpful and innocent? Morm really curious to know if the rival pack is down by one? Mith being the voice of reason? Mith trying to protect a fellow?

We will find out in six posts.

[Aganzir]

Unless the other thread gets really vocal. Not sure how many people we have around right now.

[Nerwen]

Well, I'm here.

[Aganzir]

Originally Posted by Eomer of the Rohirrim

I don't know if this is a stretch, but did anyone else have the feeling that Nilp may have been empowered by the Dead yesterday? If so, the narration is quite cryptic; but it does mention that Nilp jumped up and pulled the lever on himself - he didn't cast the deciding vote as a few people voted him after his self-vote, so I'm puzzled that he's described as pulling the lever.

Could be nothing more than a joke, of course, but if not then it would indicate that Legate was innocent.

Depending on who the Ranger is and who they tried to save (if still in the village) we might be able to narrow it down from 4 (Morm, Form, Mith & Kath) to 3 or 2. Then I'd say it's just a matter of killing them off one by one.

Note that I'm taking Sally's post yesterday as proof of a certain someone's innocence, but if that was some sort of in-joke then we should really get that confirmed.

He forgot McC though!

I don't have time to go back to look at sally's posts right now but if there's something that suggests her lover is still alive, all the better for us all.

[Aganzir]

Okay got to go now. Nerwen, take us to 1,050.

[Rikae]

Originally Posted by Mithalwen

Not sure that Lalaith is the most useful information at this point. If Nerwen were the Seer she may have had her dreams before she died. Wouldn't it be more useful to contrive something to find out something out abput the living since we must be nearing a very delicate stage.

Personally speaking, while it would make days easier to be a proven innocent such identification post lynch vote might be counterproductive in that it pins a nice target for the wolves. So maybe only ask them to identify a known wolf.. obviously not by giving them the bonus vote but with either prearranged "pairs" or other system?

She's right, and therefore will be completely ignored.

EDIT: Next post, #1047, at 9:51

Originally Posted by me

I should really let Nerwen have this post, but she doesn't seem to be around, so:

[Nilpaurion Felagund]

They still haven't noticed the lack of highlighted onomatopoeia in my death scene.

Also,

I am not saying I regard myself as above suspicion, on the contrary a case could have been made from the first days when I was bored and frustrated from having no certainties, pointless philosophising and being expected to be no more than a playing piece in the phantom's game.

Yup, she is my mother.

[Macalaure]

Originally Posted by Nilpaurion Felagund

Esty and Mr Underhill have 100% win rates, right? Unless they joined a game while I was away or you have a minimum number of games played requirement.

Yes, they do. Along with 15 others, most of them obscure.

I usually go with a minimum of 10 games played, to make it a bit more significant.

The average percentage was 45.5%, by the way, since the wolves were a bit more successful than the village, at least up to that game.

[Macalaure]

If we get to 1100 before the living get to 750, I'll add a bonus and give you the name of someone who is not a wolf with me.

[Legate of Amon Lanc]

Just quickly running through, will be back later... but I see, looks like you did it, nice, folks

Originally Posted by Rikae

Morm is probably going to wait until a few of us have probably voted due to time zones, and then switch his list around.

Certainly. Anyway, I think we should give the lists toDay only secondary importance and vote most of all to empower someone who votes for Wolf (preferably one with more chance to get lynched). If we can get any extra info, of course the better.

[Macalaure]

Originally Posted by Rikae

Morm is probably going to wait until a few of us have probably voted due to time zones, and then switch his list around.

Good man!