The Middle Earth Popularity Cup

[Ibrîniðilpathânezel]

Originally Posted by Aganzir

Besides aren't you just happy that hopefully at least one Sil hero will now make it to the finals?

If I were to choose a Sil hero I'd like to see in the finals, it would be Finrod or Earendil. Maybe even Cirdan. But I find Turin marginally less annoying than Sam (and the coin flip went his way, anyhow).

Hmm, perhaps this could've been split into two contests, one for the Third Age and one for the First (maybe even one for the Second). There wouldn't've been the issue of divided loyalties, then (nor some of the amusing banter, alas ).