Arwen vs. Galadriel

[Lalwendë]

Originally Posted by Andsigil

Hmmm... I wouldn't have preferred her.

Kiera Knightly has a chin like a boot-toe and one of the largest underbites in the film industry. Add to that her complete lack of feminine curves, and I don't see what people find attractive in her.

Andsigil has the ladies flocking to his door now

I just couldn't believe Liv being a Warrior Princess - it didn't work for me. Maybe as she was so good at being ethereal it didn't seem right when she was being a Riot Grrl? Or maybe it's down to PJ having messed with the original roles too much? But Keira (however you spell her name ) seems to have that tough/pretty thing down in spades - as seen in King Arthur and Pirates.