The Greatest Warrior...

[Raynor]

Originally Posted by The Saucepan Man

You misunderstand me. I am not talking about whether Turin was most powerful, skilful etc warrior. But he was the warrior who achieved the ultimate greatness, and so, surely, the greatest warrior of Arda.

I disagree with this logic. If the bulk of the merit for defeating Melkor would go either Fionwe, Tulkas or Earendil, then giving the greatest title to the guy that gives the last punch does not seem appropriate to me. That last blow might be something purely "formal", and we don't know either way. Then again, we might have to agree to disagree.