Tol-in-Gaurhoth XLVII: Dueling Wizards Werewolf II

[Isabellkya]

In response to Brin, my vote was almost completely random. It was random out of the people whom I had an inkling of suspicion towards yesterDay - coupled with the fact that it was nearing deadline. Well what I thought was deadline, but alas I'd forgotten I'm in PDT not PST.

Pah. Just when I want to go away from phantom, I read one of his posts.. and he says something... mildly interesting.
..... "tear her post up like a piece of paper,' in reference to Roa.

I skimmed that lengthy post. I just want to chalk all of his (phantom's) shenanigans and theatrics to trying to do anything and everything, to be scried by both sides; though obviously not in the same Night.

Either way, I'm not entirely sure of Roa's and Phantom's innocent village intentions. Oh yes, they both have Village intentions, but I am doubting that they are for the good.

Originally Posted by Brin

Well, I suspected Aganzir yesterDay before Volo was a known innocent and I still suspect her toDay. I see nothing wrong with using a known innocent's quote to support my feelings about another player. Of course, Volo could easily be wrong with her, but as I do suspect Aganzir I think he may be onto something...

All well and good, but you shouldn't be using the "known innocent" status to try and add weight to your suspicions and arguments. A known-dead innocent does not equal all knowing.


X'd since the end of Page 11. Dear me, every time I think I'm caught up, another page and a half pops up.

[Durelin]

Soooo...any possibility of '(The) Durinator' sticking?

[Diamond18]

Originally Posted by Durelin

Soooo...any possibility of '(The) Durinator' sticking?

Put it in your signature. That will help.

[Brinniel]

Hmm...I'm tired of hearing people say "at least one of these two are evil" and "if this person's evil the other one has to be evil"

Of course it's possible that the wolves know each other, or one's a wolf and one's the EW. But it's also possible that the wolves don't know each other and are attacking each other (or a wolf's attacking the EW). We can't suspect or disregard someone solely based on how they treated someone who has been proven innocent or guilty...

[Cailín]

Originally Posted by Isabellkya

All well and good, but you shouldn't be using the "known innocent" status to try and add weight to your suspicions and arguments. A known-dead innocent does not equal all knowing.

A good point; unfortunately one which must be made in every werewolf game.