Werewolf LIII: The Republic

[A Little Green]

I WOULDN'T LYNCH TODAY:
Brinniel - Still nothing new.
Gil-Galad - Kath raised a good point about him: he wouldn't have made the Night kill since he doesn't appear at all during the Day.. Or at least, if he does that I'm going to strangle him personally.
Greenie - Well obviously.
Lommy - Still the one who seems the most innocentish this far.
Kath - Seems innocentish and has good points I think a wolf would not raise.
Nerwen - Seems innocentish as well.
Rune - The same with him. I have no reason to suspect he's a wolf. Especially his voting twice for morm seems like something a wolf wouldn't do.
the phantom - Obvious again.

I COULD BE PERSUADED TO LYNCH TODAY:
Gwathagor - I wouldn't be surprised if he was the last wolf, though he isn't necessarily my top suspect. Does not seem innocentish but not especially wolvish either.
Ilya - I'm still very torn about her. She keeps sending both innocent and wolvish vibes and I can't decide between them.. Leaning suspicious.
Sally - She's the one I'm most uneasy with. No, not because of the double-lynch thingy. Her posts toDay have seemed overall fishy. I'll have a better look at her soon and try to get some concrete examples.

Any ideas of our lynch my fellow reps, and others too?

[Nerwen]

Originally Posted by A Little Green

Gil-Galad - Kath raised a good point about him: he wouldn't have made the Night kill since he doesn't appear at all during the Day.. Or at least, if he does that I'm going to strangle him personally.

I move that if he turns out to be a wolf we strangle the moddesses too– because that would be totally unfair.

Originally Posted by A Little Green

Kath - Seems innocentish and has good points I think a wolf would not raise.

Agreed, although don't forget that her failure to spend the first two Days trying to lynch Nogrod is pretty darned unusual.

Originally Posted by A Little Green

Gwathagor - I wouldn't be surprised if he was the last wolf, though he isn't necessarily my top suspect. Does not seem innocentish but not especially wolvish either.

He's posted so rarely that I can't really remember what he's said. I'd like to gather all his posts together, Brinniel-style. (I know Kath has summarised his posts, but I don't like relying on someone else's version.) I need to get some sleep now, though.

Originally Posted by A Little Green

Ilya - I'm still very torn about her. She keeps sending both innocent and wolvish vibes and I can't decide between them.. Leaning suspicious.

This is much my own impression... however, if Wolf #4 is Ilya, she's playing an awfully cool hand (paw?) under the circumstances.

Originally Posted by A Little Green

Sally - She's the one I'm most uneasy with. No, not because of the double-lynch thingy. Her posts toDay have seemed overall fishy. I'll have a better look at her soon and try to get some concrete examples.

What I want to see is whether she really can put together any kind of case against me– that is, I want some idea of whether she believes what she's saying.

About the triple-lynch business– it wasn't just the fact that she suggested the triple-lynch, it was the way she led up to it, too:

[Note: Posts are not quoted in full]

#1264 [replying to tp, who asked if anyone could see a flaw in his plan]

Originally Posted by satansaloser2005

In all seriousness, I've noticed, but I figured if I didn't say anything maybe no one else would think of it. *shrug* We'll make it work no matter what.

#1267 [when asked what the "flaw" was]

Originally Posted by satansaloser2005

No, no, not like that. It's just going to be too easy for the other wolf to hide in amongst us all. And I was wondering about a couple other things as well, but it's more of a "Sally being Sally" thing.

The lynch plan itself is perfectly fine.

Comment: if she's a wolf, this could be an attempt to stall and undermine confidence.

Then she backtracks:

#1270

Originally Posted by satansaloser2005

Oi, I didn't say it was a bad plan. In fact, I'm quite sure I said it was a very good plan, thanks very much.

Then she comes up with her famous triple-lynch proposal:

#1297

Originally Posted by satansaloser2005

[makes case against Gil-Galad]
With that in mind, is anyone else up for a triple lynch? Obviously we could put it off until toMorrow if you so desired, but why wait if we can do it toDay?


(Oh, and Phantom, that was the 'flaw' that I mentioned earlier. Heh told you the plan was fine. I just wanted to make additions)

So... suddenly the "flaw" is the fact that the plan doesn't allow triple-lynching?

I find this to be quite a suspicious little sequence.

However, I also think I've been concentrating far too much on Sally. I need to look at other people more.

EDIT: X'd with Rune and Greenie.

[Rune Son of Bjarne]

I only find that it was the first of those 3 quotes that was odd, the others seem to fit together just fine and I don't find wanting a triple lynch overly suspicious.

Maybe it is just because people always frown upon the slightest mention of multiple lynches that I find it odd that a wolf would sugest such a thing, it would certainly attract unwanted attention.