WW: LXXVI - At Moria: EXTRA Edition

[satansaloser2005]

Originally Posted by Nerwen

But why did you think I was the Seer, then? Who did you think I had dreamed?

Well I thought you were gifted, and I just kind of placed a seer label on you, I suppose. I figured Boro was safer making the "hints" he was if (assuming he'd been being truthful) he was the ranger or hunter.


I had no idea. That was one of my tasks to investigate. But then you told us, so I was like "derp, I should have seen that coming".


Laundry time. Back in a couple. Oh, and I'm having some serious eye issues tonight so in advance forgive any and all typos and any misreading I may do. Thanks so much (and I can't wait to get new glasses)!

[Blind Guardian]

Btw, Noia's a wolf. 'cause I know.

[Nerwen]

Originally Posted by satansaloser2005

Well I thought you were gifted, and I just kind of placed a seer label on you, I suppose. I figured Boro was safer making the "hints" he was if (assuming he'd been being truthful) he was the ranger or hunter.


I had no idea. That was one of my tasks to investigate. But then you told us, so I was like "derp, I should have seen that coming".

And yet, Sally, if you think a person is the Seer, and that person keeps going after another, repeatedly says he "feels furry" etc., and finally outright asks you to lynch him... well, I mean, there's a pretty obvious conclusion to be reached there, no?

EDIT:X'd with tum and Wolf Guardian.

[Inziladun]

Originally Posted by autume98

Thanks for pointing that out. Like I said I would have to go back, and I still hadn't the chance to do that. I had forgotten about the part where people were finding Boro suspicious due to his vote. (I probably shouldn't look at WW while I'm at work, and I end up playing with one eye over my shoulder ) And I kinda was on for over an hour according to the time stamps.

The work thing I can understand, because I do a lot on playing on the clock myself. But really, that scheme of Boro's to vote McCaber was plainly not helpful to the innocent side. You already knew Boro was under the gun for his vote for Lottie, and then he comes up with a horrible plan to lynch a modfire! That ought to have given you some pause.

Originally Posted by Nerwen

And yet, Sally, if you think a person is the Seer, and that person keeps going after another, repeatedly says he "feels furry" etc., and finally outright asks you to lynch him... well, I mean, there's a pretty obvious conclusion to be reached there, no?

That's my point. Yet Sally kept dragging her feet on Boro til you were forced to reveal.

[autume98]

So I feel like being productive. So I've decided to create a list.

Suspicious:
Wolf BeiGe
Morsul?

Somewhat Suspicious:
Noia - however I'm kinda leaning towards innocent cause I don't think a fellow wolf would rat out a fellow wolf unless they are trying to be sneaky.
Xed
Sally - Some good points have been made, but then it could just be Sally being Sally.

Innocent:
Nerwen
Me
Lottie
Inzil
Mira

Xed with everyone since my last post

[Inziladun]

Originally Posted by autume98

So I feel like being productive. So I've decided to create a list.

Suspicious:
Wolf BeiGe
Morsul?

Somewhat Suspicious:
Noia - however I'm kinda leaning towards innocent cause I don't think a fellow wolf would rat out a fellow wolf unless they are trying to be sneaky.
Xed
Sally - Some good points have been made, but then it could just be Sally being Sally.

Innocent:
Nerwen
Me
Lottie
Inzil
Mira

Aren't you missing someone? And why is Morsul suspicious, ranked with the (almost) known Wolfguardian?

EDIT- I see now that you did put in Xed, which I assume is Celuien.

[satansaloser2005]

Originally Posted by Nerwen

And yet, Sally, if you think a person is the Seer, and that person keeps going after another, repeatedly says he "feels furry" etc., and finally outright asks you to lynch him... well, I mean, there's a pretty obvious conclusion to be reached there, no?

EDIT:X'd with tum and Wolf Guardian.

Erm, dear, everyone was suspecting Boro yesterDay. You asked me to vote for him, I'm like "oh, this can end either really well or really poorly". I'm innocent, stupid, and busy. I'm allowed to miss things, aren't I? Also, with all the attention on Boro isn't it safe for me to have assumed that you suspected him and wanted him lynched over an innocent you dreamed? That'd make sense too, wouldn't it? *shrugs* I'm just sayin'. This wolf/witch hunt is going nowhere fast because I was trying to protect any possible gifteds, for better or worse, and I refuse to be punished for trying to help my village.

Originally Posted by Nerwen

Oh, and in another hour I will announce my second dream.

This excites me. 'Cause I'll still be awake (hopefully) then.


EDIT: x'd with Tum, and fixing some of those whoopsies I warned about earlier

[autume98]

Originally Posted by Inziladun

And why is Morsul suspicious, ranked with the (almost) known Wolfguardian?

EDIT- I see now that you did put in Xed, which I assume is Celuien.

Yes Xed is Celuien.

There's not really a lot to go off on Morsul. Maybe it's just me not getting a very good read on him. This is from Day 1.

Originally Posted by Morsul the Dark

SHASTA: Reading through I noticed you put Blind on the "Didn't Vote" list she voted but late... just to defend her real quick before doing this.

She voted Nienna for absolutely no stated reasons. Spent 2 pages with nothing but banter Gets overly defensive when someone points it out and keeps reminding everyone how innocent she is and new to WW(Which seems forced and fake to me)

++Blind Guardian

I don't know Morsul very well. I've only played with him one other game, and he gave me bad vibes that game too. Although he turned out to be an Ordo in that game, so maybe he is an Ordo this game. However for now I'm going to keep him on my suspicious list.

He defends BeiGe then votes for BeiGe. Granted we now know that BeiGe is a wolf. Could it be a wolf on wolf though? This just doesn't sit well with me. If you think that Morsul is innocent please do tell me why.

Edit: x-ed with Sally, Sally again, and BeiGe

[satansaloser2005]

You know, if Paranoia really is a wolf, I'm going to be quite cross, because it would be horribly unsportsmanlike for Blind to sell out her packmate. Yes, I know, we do it all the time, but we're kidding and/or being very clever and sneaky. I think I'm just....paranoiad?


(Shut up. I couldn't resist the joke, lamesauce.)

[satansaloser2005]

Also, if Paranoia's a wolf, I can see that last post being used against me like mad. Even I would think I was cautioning my newbie wolf. *headdesks* I give myself very good advice, but I very seldom follow it.

*misses her muffin*


EDIT: meant to italicize the I in the second sentence, but forgot. Sounds much better now.

[autume98]

Originally Posted by autume98

Yes Xed is Celuien.

There's not really a lot to go off on Morsul. Maybe it's just me not getting a very good read on him. This is from Day 1.

Actually this is from Day 2. Sorry for any confusion this may cause or has caused.

[Inziladun]

Originally Posted by autume98

He defends BeiGe then votes for BeiGe. Granted we now know that BeiGe is a wolf. Could it be a wolf on wolf though? This just doesn't sit well with me. If you think that Morsul is innocent please do tell me why.

I'm not convinced about Morsul either way.

He declined to vote the first Day (as did you), and I didn't like that.

Beyond that, he voted for BG on Day 2, as you noted, while in the same post saying he had to 'defend' her. But he was apparently only correcting the point that she had attempted to vote, though it was too late to count. I don't know that could really be called a 'defence'.

x/d with all since 408

[Paranoia]

Honestly, I don't buy into the "Sally is a wolf." bit based on her push at the end of day 2; she was actively pushing the Blind Wolf lynch right up until Nerwen's seer claim; honestly I find it doubtful that she even would do this, as if her aim was to save Boro, she would have pushed *anyone* but BG. And if she thought Nerwen was the seer, there'd been no point in her pushing the lynch so Boro could have slipped on by today as a gifted; the only way this would make sense is if Sally planned on Nerwen being the night 2 kill. OH WAIT.

Then things make a bit more sense. Trade off a newbie wolf in favor of say... an experienced one. Kill the seer while everyone is looking elsewhere and let boro slide for a day. Maybe two; kind of unlikely in the slide by case; as far as I can tell, it was a deliberate attempt at just trying to end things before Nerwen had a chance to claim; either way, I'd kinda request that Nerwen investigate Sally.

[satansaloser2005]

Well we know she didn't last Night or she wouldn't be suspecting me toDay. I'm all up for it, because clearing innocents can be just as helpful at catching wolves as actually dreaming the wolves.

Athough I'd really like to know what Mira is, because she confuses me. o_O

[Nerwen]

Originally Posted by satansaloser2005

Erm, dear, everyone was suspecting Boro yesterDay. You asked me to vote for him, I'm like "oh, this can end either really well or really poorly". I'm innocent, stupid, and busy. I'm allowed to miss things, aren't I? Also, with all the attention on Boro isn't it safe for me to have assumed that you suspected him and wanted him lynched over an innocent you dreamed?

Really? What innocent was in danger?

–Anyway, I suppose you'd all like to know who the third wolf is.

Are you ready?

EDIT:X'd since Sally.

[Inziladun]

Originally Posted by Nerwen

Really? What innocent was in danger?

–Anyway, I suppose you'd all like to know who the third wolf is.

Are you ready?

By all means.

[Blind Guardian]

Yeah!!

[Nerwen]

It's... ta-ta-ta–

TUM!!!

[Blind Guardian]

Tum? WHo's Tum?

[satansaloser2005]

Originally Posted by Nerwen

It's... ta-ta-ta–

TUM!!!

HAHA! You have no idea how unsurprising this is to me. *dies of win* Every bit of my brain was screaming "Wolf!" but I've not yet gotten rid of my RL meta barriers of "but....but it's Tum....and she....nah....". My day, it has been made.


And again, Nerwen, stop being such a bloody rockstar. (Of course I'll happily let you wait until after you've found the fourth wolf.) The win, it is palpable.


Oh, I think I need to make a phone call. Drat. Back in a tick.


Oh, and Tum? You just lost the game. (Sorry, Lottie dear.)

[Blind Guardian]

Maybe we need Nerwen's second dream ?