WW XCVI - The Fell Winter of 2911

[Nerwen]

Originally Posted by G55

A question to the wolves: I thought you would bluff and double-bluff with Agan. I was half-convinced that you would let her live and get her lynched for that (since she could only have 2 roles: Ranger or wolf). Were you afraid the village would ask for a counter-reveal before lynching the potential Ranger? Or that Agan would make another save while you twist and scheme around her?

They probably didn't think the village would fall for it– after all, why wouldn't the real Ranger have counter-revealed immediately, if Agan was a fake? (If you, being a gifted, wait too long before challenging a false reveal, usually everyone believes the monster and lynches you.)

[Meneltarmacil]

It was great to be back. Although it's really too bad that I didn't realize what was going on until it was too late.

[Shastanis Althreduin]

Originally Posted by Nerwen

They probably didn't think the village would fall for it– after all, why wouldn't the real Ranger have counter-revealed immediately, if Agan was a fake? (If you, being a gifted, wait too long before challenging a false reveal, usually everyone believes the monster and lynches you.)

Except in certain cases. *coughBorocough*

And as for the Day 3 shenanigans - well, I've been screwed over by last-minute out-of-nowhere votes before (see - wintywinty), and with Menel not around anywhere to gauge, I felt it was too risky to vote Nog then.